OCOs are a unique danger --- they’re not securitized.
Gomez 16 – Senior Researcher at the Center for Security Studies at ETH Zurich, Assistant Lecturer at De La Salle University, M.A. in International Security from the Institut Barcelona d’Estudis Internacionals
Miguel Alberto N. Gomez, “Arming Cyberspace: The Militarization of a Virtual Domain,” Global Security and Intelligence Studies, Spring, https://www.ibei.org/arming-cyberspace-the-militarization-of-a-virtual-domain_54871.pdf
Conclusions and Future Direction
The growing number of OCOs being attributed to state or state-sponsored actors demands a better understanding of the underlying factors that result in the militarization of cyberspace. While the existing literature posits two seemingly incompatible arguments centered on either fear-based rhetoric or rational choice, the study has demonstrated that both these factors account for the varying levels to which cyberspace has been militarized across states.
On the one hand, while increasing societal use of information communication technologies have led to greater risks associated with these technologies, the capabilities developed that are necessary to mitigate such could similarly lead to the transform the domain of cyberspace for use in warfare. Aside from the re-tasking of defense technologies, there is now the appearance of technologies once associated with the criminal elements of cyberspace in OCOs attributed to state or state-sponsored actors. The malleability of this technology supports the argument that increasing use alone does not account for the militarization of this domain, but rather the ability to maximize the functionality provides those with this skillset to expand beyond the traditional domains of air, land, and sea.
Equally important—and thus linking the two existent theories—is the continued relevance of conventional military capabilities vis-à-vis the use of cyberspace. While there is no doubt as to the advantages offered by this virtual domain, namely its asymmetric characteristics, low cost of entry, and challenges of attribution; these exist in conjunction with the stated policy goals of a state. The ability to employ this domain is dependent on conventional military capabilities to consolidate whatever gains were obtained in the process. Although it would be theoretically possible to utilize OCOs to disrupt a state’s critical infrastructure in times of war, the impermanence of the damage caused requires additional resources to be brought to bear in order to force a change in policy or behavior of a given adversary.
Viewed as the causal explanations for the militarization of cyberspace, the risk faced by a state may be understood as the catalyst that encourages the militarization of this domain. However, without conventional military capabilities that could be used to apply constant pressure on one’s adversaries, viewing OCOs as a revolution in military affairs is of limited value.
With this in mind, what role do the other aspects (e.g., regime type, rivalry, and elite influence) identified by the literature have on militarization? Although the study has not demonstrated that these to have a direct causal influence on militarization, this does not suggest that no relationship exists. As previously mentioned, the nature of the quantitative techniques applied could lead to differing results if the number of observations is increased. Regime type, for instance, could influence the type of risk faced by states and, in turn, influence the technologies developed to meet these risk. Hare’s model captures this and is seen clearly in cases of states such as that of the United States and the People’s Republic of China (PRC). The former perceives threats to its critical infrastructure and other services in cyberspace. Consequently, this prompts the development of technologies to ensure resilience and pro-active prevention of disruptive events. The latter, in contrast, is concerned with dissent and political activism in cyberspace. Consequently, this results in the emergence of censorship technologies that do not translate directly to offensive capabilities in cyberspace— though espionage-related capabilities would benefit from these (Giles and Hagestad 2013; Hare 2010).
Similarly, perceived risk originating from internal threats could account for the decision to engage (or not) in OCOs against other rival states. However, cases such as that of the PRC do not follow this line of reasoning as the most prominent of their activities in this domain have been directed against their military, political, and economic rivals.
Lastly, the influence of elites in the militarization of this domain could, in the view of authors such as Nissenbaum, be constrained by a lack of understanding of its nature and the continued lack of synergy between experts in technology and national policy (Hansen and Nissenbaum 2009). This would lead to a situation wherein political elites could, and do, vocalize the dangers posed by cyberspace but lack the proper understanding of how to apply these technologies as a tool to support national policies and goals.
The manner in which states conceptualize cyberspace at this point in time finds parallels with that of the mid-twentieth century and the advent of nuclear war. While the technology of the time offered to revolutionize warfare, few understood the implications of such and the extent with which these would alter the relationship between states and their respective military strategies.