Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← SearchGeorgetown2022Affirmative
Opening Word document…

Closer integration with Europe is key to prevent EU-Chinese coop that allows them to win the race

Schuman 2-16-2021, MA, international affairs, correspondent for TIME. (Michael, "Europe can’t stay neutral in US-China stand-off", POLITICO, https://www.politico.eu/article/europe-cant-stay-neutral-in-us-china-stand-off/)

China also represents a long-term economic threat to Europe — not merely because it is an advancing competitor in a global market economy, but because Beijing’s policies are designed to use and abuse that open world economy to eventually dominate it. Beijing’s leadership makes no secret of its goal to foster high-tech industries and national champions to overtake its established Western rivals, fueled by untold billions of state aid. By one estimate, the Chinese government has lavished more than $100 billion on its electric vehicle sector, in the form of subsidies for buyers, research and development support and other aid. Another $49 billion has been committed to create a Chinese competitor to Airbus. Partnerships with European companies are vital to the success of China’s agenda. Beijing sees joint ventures and other corporate cooperation with foreign companies as a way to extract the advanced technology and know-how required for China to catch up to, and then leapfrog over, the Western world. An October report from the Foundation for Defense of Democracies argues that the Chinese are targeting key sectors of the German economy — including industrial equipment and electronics — with the aim of pillaging them. China’s economic relations with Germany are “a template for the CCP strategy to dominate the 21st-century economy and set the rules for the modern world,” the report contends. In other words, by continuing to engage with China, Germany is gaining today, but paving the way to its doom tomorrow. There’s little chance European politicians can talk China into a better relationship. After seven years of negotiations, the EU’s recent investment agreement with China “amounts to so little,” lamented Brussels-based think tank Bruegel in a January analysis. Littered with vague pledges and lacking methods of enforcement, Bruegel noted that even on market access, the agreement’s primary focus, “only a few concessions have been made bilaterally and all of them are limited.” Simply hoping the Chinese will play fair is naïve. While Beijing threatens and blusters that Europeans must keep their markets open to 5G gear from Huawei, the Chinese are sidelining European telecom firms in the China market. Ultimately, China is simply not a true partner for Europe. The longer Europeans fail to grasp this, the weaker their position will become. China will continue to exploit the divisions between democracies to advance its interests. European politicians will strain relations with the U.S. by cynically reaping economic benefits from China while Washington does all the fighting. By the time Europe realizes it needs America’s help, it could discover Washington has found other, more reliable friends. Ultimately, the choice between the U.S. and China should be determined by what Europeans want their role in the world to be. They could defend the liberal order they helped create and continue to participate in global leadership. Or they could sit back and watch authoritarian China knock away the pillars of the current order, and the sources of European influence with them. Is the choice really that hard?

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.