OCO sharing OR a NATO posture shift causes Russia to freak-out and undermines strategic stability.
Lewis 15 — James Lewis, Senior Vice President and Director of the Strategic Technologies Program at the Center for Strategic and International Studies, former Senior Advisor to UN Groups of Governmental Experts on Information Security, PhD from the University of Chicago, 2015 (“The Role of Offensive Cyber Operations in NATO’s Collective Defense,” The Tallinn Papers, Available Online at https://ccdcoe.org/uploads/2018/10/TP_08_2015_0.pdf)
Dissimulation is an essential part of hybrid warfare, and Europe and the US face a propaganda barrage that is much more sophisticated than the clumsy Soviet efforts of the Cold War. Despite this clumsiness, a good portion of the Western public has found it persuasive. Similarly, those critical of NATO will find new complaints about aggression and militarisation credible. Russia has already complained that NATO’s defensive cyber doctrine is destabilising warmongering and part of a larger conspiracy to advance western hegemony.11 The Snowden revelations have lent a powerful impetus to Russian propaganda.
Behind the rhetoric lies both a desire to conceal their own use of cyber operations and a real fear that Russia’s decline leaves it vulnerable to new military technologies. The intent is to hamper and complicate any Western response to Russian efforts to regain control in Crimea and the “near abroad”. The Russian position is that NATO’s new cyber doctrine is destabilising as it threatens to use conventional or even nuclear responses (in the Russian description of the new policy towards low-level cyber attacks).
Any announcement by NATO relating to offensive cyber capabilities would be greeted with alarm and vitriol in Moscow. However, the effect on stability would likely be less pronounced. NATO-Russia relations are already in steep decline. It is possible that any NATO announcement would accelerate this, but it is also possible that Russia could recalculate the risk of further adventures if it were faced with a stronger defence. In terms of opponent attitudes, there is probably little effect. Russia, along with NATO’s other potential military opponents, is likely to overestimate both capabilities and coordination among NATO member states and underestimate NATO’s will to defend. This is an unhappy combination as it makes aggression against NATO seem less risky.
NATO’s decision on how cyber attacks could trigger Article 5, while greeted with complaints, had a stabilising effect. It made clear to potential opponents that cyber attacks are not risk-free. Similarly, a clear enunciation of how NATO would use offensive cyber capabilities as part of any defensive operation would also change opponents’ risk calculations in ways that would force them to consider how offensive actions, even if intended to be covert, are not free of risk or cost.
The Cyber Club
Some level of cyber capability is being acquired by all advanced militaries, and perhaps a dozen countries can be identified from public sources as procuring offensive cyber capabilities. These countries include several NATO members. As with nuclear weapons, the capability to undertake offensive cyber operations is a club within a club in NATO, with largely the same membership – the US, the UK and France. Germany’s armed forces may also be developing offensive cyber capabilities.12 The well-developed procedures for release and for integration into NATO planning created for nuclear weapons do not exist for cyber attack, although it is currently far more likely that any NATO military operation will have a cyber component, while the use of nuclear weapons is almost unthinkable.
The US and the UK both possess elite cyber capabilities. They also have a close partnership in cyber espionage. This partnership is centred on a relationship between the US National Security Agency (NSA) and the British Government Communications Headquarters (GCHQ), both of which are intelligence agencies with a long history of supporting military operations. US military cyber operations are the responsibility of U.S. Cyber Command, whose commander is also the head of the NSA. Cyber operations blur the line between intelligence and military activities. The fact, however, that these are intelligence agencies has a created a certain reticence regarding the sharing of information on capabilities and plans, which complicates the integration of offensive cyber into NATO planning and doctrine.
Offensive cyber capabilities are still too new, with too many unknown risks that hold potentially profound political consequences. US policy is that only the President can approve a cyber operation likely to result in “significant consequences” that could produce loss of life or a damaging reaction, although the Secretary of Defense or the head of U.S. Cyber Command can take independent action in an emergency. US policy restricts independent action by tactical and operational commanders for this reason. A local commander may not know all the trade-offs or the risks that using a cyber attack could entail. That said, all of these problems are manageable with some decision-making model based on the precedent of the warning and request system used for nuclear weapons release.13
Until there are better predictive tools and judgments about risk and consequences, offensive cyber operations will require a politically sensitive decision as to when the benefit of an attack outweighs the political risk. Additional coordination mechanisms would be needed to decide when the benefits of an attack outweigh the risk of a loss of intelligence capabilities, or when a target justifies expending a weapon that might never work again. The inability to predict collateral damage and uncertainty over political effect encourage caution in the use of offensive cyber operations, but that is not the same as advertising possession of the capability.