Interop Fails---1NC
Interoperability challenges are structural---they can’t be fixed through consultation or dialogue.
Edward Hunter Christie 22, Senior Research Fellow at the Finnish Institute of International Affairs, “Defence Cooperation in Artificial Intelligence: Bridging the Transatlantic Gap for a Stronger Europe,” European View, vol. 21, no. 1, SAGE Publications Ltd, 04/01/2022, pp. 13–21
Interoperability challenges
Interoperability can be defined as ‘the ability of systems, units or forces to provide services to, and accept services from other systems, units or forces and the use the services so exchanged to enable them to operate effectively together’ (Dufour 2018, 1).
The first general challenge to interoperability is the overall gap between the US and Europe in terms of total defence investment, as well as in terms of civilian technological attainment with respect to AI and related technologies. There is no single solution to this problem, which is much broader in scope than traditional military–technical standards, such as those pursued in the NATO context through existing mechanisms. For this broad challenge, overall policy decisions relating to national investment choices and technology policy coordination between the two sides of the Atlantic are of particular importance. Further discussion of this follows in the sections on investment challenges and international security challenges.
A second challenge to interoperability is that, as far as digital technologies are concerned, the civilian sector of the economy, on both sides of the Atlantic, is more advanced, more dynamic and also not especially oriented towards meeting military needs. For decades, the military sector has represented only a very small share of the total sales volume of the computing and semiconductor industries. The same pattern is repeating itself currently with AI. This stands in great contrast to narrower dual-use technologies, for example aerospace, where the military sector remains inherently important. With digital technologies, defence institutions are under much more pressure to either adapt to civilian industry products and standards or to pay a significant premium to suppliers to secure military-grade equipment and software.
A third challenge to interoperability lies in how AI is implemented in practice. To set up a bespoke machine-learning algorithm in a given data environment, best practice in the software industry is to pursue some variant of ‘agile’ development. This involves a very different product-development cycle, essentially proceeding with multiple rapid iterations of an imperfect product that is released in preliminary versions and later revised—like software products released in various ‘beta versions’—with upgrades developed over time. This contrasts greatly with the traditional production of major military platforms, which puts a premium on strict quality control and compliance with requirements at every development step—an approach referred to in the software industry as ‘waterfall’ development (Christie 2021b, 87). Agile product development may pose challenges to interoperability. Unless very tight standards are applied, there is a considerable risk of divergences in how different national institutions go about solving a particular AI or data analytics problem.
With large traditional military platforms there are long time frames during which states can take coordination steps, either by purchasing the same platforms, or by building consensus in terms of requirements and standards. However, when a comparatively small team works dynamically to generate an algorithmic solution to a particular problem in a matter of weeks or months, traditional coordination through existing consultation mechanisms may pose risks to the speed advantage inherent to agile development. Conversely, once a solution has been developed, its adoption in somewhat different environments may be challenging for a range of technical reasons. None of these issues is insurmountable, but they do pose, in a new light, classical trade-offs between the benefits of inventiveness and dynamism, on the one hand, and those of imposing constraints through standards and other harmonising measures to ensure that new products can be broadly used and shared on the other. In the case of AI, a typical observation is that there are many excellent prototypes and pilot projects in numerous defence institutions, but there are also serious outstanding challenges in terms of scaling up to enterprise-wide solutions, let alone Alliance-wide solutions.