Chinese AI dominance is the death knell of global peace---sparks great power wars
Allison 20 – Professor of Government, Harvard Kennedy School
Graham Allison, August 2020, "Is China Beating the U.S. to AI Supremacy?," Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs,
An AI Arms Race?
During the Cold War, the stakes in the nuclear arms race with the Soviet Union were obvious. In today’s Thucydidean rivalry between a meteorically rising China and a colossal ruling United States, what are the risks of an escalating AI arms race?
Like it or not, future war will be AI-driven. As Secretary of Defense Mark Esper recently noted at the conference of the National Security Commission on AI, “Advances in AI have the potential to change the character of warfare for generations to come. Whichever nation harnesses AI first will have a decisive advantage on the battlefield for many, many years.” AI’s ability to accelerate decision cycles in conflict will compel militaries to adopt it. In air-to-air combat, pilots begin with an ooda loop: observe, orient, decide, act. If A can “get inside B’s OODA loop,” A wins—since he can maneuver to escape A’s fire and attack where he calculates B’s path will leave him when A’s missile arrives. Because AI can observe, orient, decide and act at multiples of a human pilot, it will become irresponsible to send a human pilot into battle with an AI piloted aircraft.51 As former Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff Joeseph Dunford put it: “Whoever has the competitive advantage in artificial intelligence and can field systems informed by artificial intelligence, could very well have an overall competitive advantage.”52
The demonstrated success of AlphaGo, and more recently, AlphaStar, in defeating all competitors in one of the world’s most complex real-time strategy video games suggests that in any structured contest between offense and defense, AI will dominate humans. The company, country or team with the best AI will win. As an example, consider American football. In what commentators often discuss as a “chess match,” the offense and defense coordinators know that if the defense guesses correctly whether the next play will be a pass or a run, most nfl teams’ defenses can successfully stop most opponents’ offense. Reading all the variables in a situation, AI should be able to tilt the scales on the field—or in analogous military competitions on land, sea, and in the air and space.
The domain’s leader will also be the first to know which of today’s military mainstays AI will upend. Germany discovered the power of submarines before World War I because it led in their development. British admirals did not wake up to their deadly efficiency until a lone German U-boat in 1914 sank three armored cruisers on a single morning. By then, it was too late—the British had already invested their treasure in building battle fleet that had become largely obsolete. The coordination of drones and cruise missiles that successfully attacked Saudi Arabia’s most valuable target and cut its oil exports by half is suggestive. Will AI-empowered drone swarms make aircraft carriers equally obsolete, all for one one-thousandth of the cost? Will AI analysis of data from all sources pierce the invisibility of stealthy systems like the F-35 in which the United States has invested so substantially? The first country to know will be the one driving the research and development frontier.
Chinese AI dominance increases incentives for China to be assertive in foreign policy
Chang 18 – Benjamin Angel Chang is the inaugural Andrew W. Marshall Fellow at Georgetown University's Center for Security and Emerging Technology (CSET).
Benjamin Angel Chang, December 2018, “Chapter 14. AI and US-China Relations,” in “AI, China, Russia, and the Global Order: Technological, Political, Global, and Creative Perspectives,” https://nsiteam.com/social/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/AI-China-Russia-Global-WP_FINAL_forcopying_Edited-EDITED.pdf
Independent of effects on the US-China relationship, intensified PRC use of AI for domestic security may also encourage greater Chinese assertiveness. Again, I highlight two potential reasons. First, a pacified domestic sphere might free up attention for expanded external aims. China’s relative ability to weather the 2008 financial crisis significantly motivated its recently more assertive turn (Chen & Wang, 2011). Whereas many Chinese intellectuals had previously sought to emulate Western economic development, viewing the American stage of development as if a higher rung on a universally climbable ladder, the crisis incubated the view that, instead, the Chinese model might be a fine endpoint in and of itself. Similarly, if the CCP were to feel AI had successfully and permanently allowed it to address the full panoply of possible sources of broad public unrest, ranging from unbalanced growth to Xinjiang to income inequality, it would likely see this as one of the Party's Chang 109 crowning achievements in its leadership of the Chinese people. Chinese spending on domestic security has exceeded spending on external defense since 2010, with the gap increasing each year. In 2017, according to the best open-source estimate available, the former exceeded the latter by 18.6 percent (Zenz, 2018). Were the domestic sphere to be “solved,” some of this attention might then be turned outward. Second, concentrations of power generally tend to lead to more belligerence on the international stage. In particular, by substituting technology for manpower in carrying out the state's policing functions, an AI-empowered PRC may enable ever-smaller groups of elites to retain equivalent amounts of power. For de Mesquita et al. (1999, 2003), as the size of the coalition required for political survival (the "winning coalition") shrinks, corruption and war may become more likely, as leaders no longer fear being punished by other domestic actors for selfish arrangements or military defeats.37