1NC --- Info Sharing Fails
Cyber info sharing fails — too unpredictable, technical hurdles, and uncertain effects.
Jacobsen 21 — Jeppe T. Jacobsen, Visiting Scholar at New York University, former Cyber Coordinator at the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Denmark, Ph.D. candidate at the Danish Institute for International Studies and the Center for War Studies at the University of Southern Denmark, M.A. in International Politics from the University of London, M.A. in Political Science from the University of Aarhus, 2021 (“Cyber offense in NATO: challenges and opportunities,” International Affairs, May, Available Online at )
Challenges to a smooth integration of cyber effects
The abovementioned incidents have led cyber-conflict scholars to point to several technical and practical difficulties in the operational integration of cyber effects.29 In the interviews and background conversations that contributed to this study, three of these difficulties were continuously reiterated when discussing successful integration of cyber effects into NATO operational planning: the temporal dimension of developing exploits; the assessment of battle damage; and the problem of confliction.
Developing exploits—a matter of time
One of the characteristics of cyber attacks that receives most attention is the fact that they hit suddenly and without warning.30 While this is often the case, the central question for operational integration is not the speed at which they hit their target, but the speed with which the tools and techniques that exploit IT vulnerabilities in order to deliver cyber effects can be developed. Like conventional weapons, the cyber tools—the exploits or cyber weapons—take time to develop. However, an exploit is often harder to reuse than a conventional weapon, as it is more dependent on a meticulous analysis and target preparation—in this case, specifically, the target's IT infrastructure. Without knowing the adversary's IT systems and its vulnerabilities better than the adversary itself, meaningful cyber weapons are impossible to develop.
The fact that knowledge about the target is linked not only to the deployment of a weapon but also to its development influences the extent to which it can be used and reused. Stuxnet, for example, required years of development, testing and perfecting before it could deliver the intended effect on the Iranian centrifuges. Despite the techniques used in the Stuxnet malware having been found in other malware,31 Stuxnet lost its ability to destroy the centrifuges when it was discovered and the IT vulnerabilities that enabled it were patched. Importantly, part of the complexity of Stuxnet relates to the US–Israeli intention to keep the effect secret. In a hot conflict, secrecy in terms of the effect is often less important, and thus the development and deployment of cyber effects do not necessarily have to be as complex and time-consuming.
This observation does not necessarily change the fact that the development of exploits often has to precede the military confrontation in which they are intended to be used. NATO states that want to deliver cyber effects in NATO operations must try to gain access to Russia's or other potential adversaries' critical military networks to identify and exploit IT vulnerabilities. As several informants emphasized, if states wait for a conflict to escalate before they begin the development of exploits, it is most likely to be already too late.32
The alternative to penetrating adversary networks in peacetime is for states to rely on the exploitation of vulnerabilities in as many commercial off-the-shelf products as possible. This can be done, for example, by purchasing exploits from private companies offering this service, in the hope that it will then be possible to quickly create an overview of the enemy's IT infrastructure and adapt the exploits to this environment when a conflict escalates. The latter approach is more likely to succeed against adversaries with low network security, which does not apply in the case of Russia, or in contexts where less sophisticated and less closely targeted cyber effects are required.
Whether member states develop sophisticated exploits for future targeted effects or stockpile well-known exploits to cause more minor effects, they cannot—as several informants indicated—be certain that they will be able to deliver the cyber effect at the specific time it is requested by CYOC. This is because the IT vulnerabilities upon which exploits depend might not exist for ever. Cyberspace is a dynamic environment: vulnerabilities are patched, systems are updated or replaced and bad IT security practices are identified and improved. This means that exploits are temporary in nature and cannot be stored for later use.33 States must constantly ensure that the exploits still work, which requires minor adjustments when updates take place. As a consequence, the larger the military ‘cyber arsenal’, the more technically skilled human resources are needed for its maintenance. In the current labour market, where recruitment and retention of a cyber workforce is difficult, extensive investment is required for states to be able to stand ready with cyber effects available when requested.
In short, if a state is to offer a cyber effect in a NATO operation, then the state is likely to have to be able, first, to predict what Russian IT systems it is going to target months or years in advance, and second, to marshal the necessary resources to develop and maintain a large array of exploits that can be used against these systems. Even if this is successfully done, the state still faces difficulty in ensuring that an effect is delivered as promised.
Assessing effects—ensuring proportionality and discrimination
How likely is it that the requested cyber effect will be delivered? The answer to this question is not clear, in respect of either its preparation or its execution. This is not only because IT vulnerabilities are constantly discovered and patched; it is also because of the difficulty of assessing the effects and possible side-effects of an exploit when navigating and analysing complex IT infrastructures. In other words, reconnaissance is difficult in cyberspace, and so is the containment of effects. The Russian attempt to use ransomware aimed at disrupting critical Ukrainian infrastructure in 2017, for example, succeeded—but simultaneously encrypted computers globally, causing substantial economic damage to multinational businesses such as Maersk and FedEx.34
Collateral damage and unintended consequences are serious issues for NATO. The alliance takes pride in its adherence to the principles laid out in international law, such as proportionality and discrimination, as former NATO Deputy Assistant Secretary-General Jamie Shea has emphasized.35 Thus, disruptions of servers with huge negative implications for civilians, or the use of generic cyber tools that risk spreading their effects far and wide, are most likely not going to be considered for use in NATO operations. Indeed, one of the main challenges to US efforts to disrupt servers in working against ISIS was finding ways to ensure that civilians were not hit by their cyber effects.36
Another aspect of the difficulty of assessing the cyber effect relates to adversaries' cyber defence efforts. For the more sophisticated players in cyberspace, cyber defence has developed into more than simply patching, clearing and updating systems. Cyber defence is also increasingly about following an intruder's activity in one's own network and creating ‘honeypots’ or ‘honeynets’; or about following data traffic back to the intruder's network. In short, cyber defence is also about deception and active defence.37 This approach to cyber defence offers valuable insights into the intruder's techniques and strategies; but the mere knowledge that deception is becoming a predominant defensive strategy also introduces doubts into the intruder's assessment of possible effects.
Consequently, as Russia is considered a peer competitor with considerable cyber-defensive capacities, one informant expressed scepticism about the extent to which smaller member states are confident in their ability to deliver a cyber effect when it is requested by NATO.38 This is especially the case if operational success depends on a specific effect. Even if a state has developed the appropriate exploit, it must also be able to verify that the effect is achieved and ensure that the effect is contained to minimize collateral damage. And even if a state is confident about its current ability to contain and verify an effect, it must also be confident that it can deliver, verify and contain the effect at the specific time in the future when CYOC requests it.
The process of integration is further complicated by the fact that NATO must be willing to hand over to contributing states the responsibility for making battle damage assessments and collateral damage estimations. As the following subsection shows, states are generally unwilling to share classified information about exploits. Hence, the delegated NATO commander is unlikely to receive much useful information about how cyber effects are delivered before a decision about their deployment must be taken. As commanders would prefer to have control over the capabilities used, member-state cyber effects are likely choices of method only if alternative, conventional effects are unavailable.
The challenges associated with assessing cyber effects are naturally most significant in relation to those effects that enable other kinetic effects that are necessary to achieve operational success. For cyber effects that seek to maintain a persistent annoyance of Russian networks, these challenges are less of an issue. If the aim is to create confusion and drain resources by targeting networks and operations that are otherwise difficult and expensive to disrupt using conventional means, then cyber effects can support strategic goals without causing irreversible damage to civilians. As I will conclude at the end of this section, such a change demands an adaptation of the way in which CYOC operates.