Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

1 – standing – Courts routinely dismiss suits for lacking

Donald A. Dechert 18, III, J.D. Candidate, Valparaiso University (2018); B.A., Valparaiso University (2003); A.A.S., Cochise College (2008); MA, University of Chicago (2010). "Note: Perpetual Warfare: Proposing a New American Constitutional Amendment for the War Powers." Valparaiso University Law Review, 52, 457, pp. 467-469, Spring, 2018, Lexis, nihara

Multiple parties have sought to litigate the War Powers Resolution. 59 The War Powers Resolution has proven resistant to litigation. 60 The first problem is standing discussed in Part II.B.1.a. 61 Beyond standing are other judicial doctrines barring litigation in Part II.B.1.b. 62

a. Standing for Plaintiff to a Lawsuit, whether member of Congress or not

Standing is a fundamental constitutional concept. 63 If plaintiffs lack standing, courts dismiss the lawsuit. 64 Standing means that plaintiffs can show particularized injury in their complaint, and does not include taxpayers. 65 Two types of plaintiffs have brought lawsuits over the War Powers Resolution and military force: (1) members of Congress and (2) everyone else. 66

Members of the military, part of the everyone-elses, can also bring suit like Captain Smith, whose complaint recited his injuries to show standing. 67 His presumed legal injuries, however, did not grant standing, and the courts have found other reasons to dismiss on standing for military members. 68 Therefore, standing is the initial constitutional hurdle that plaintiffs must overcome. 69

Member of Congress have also tried to litigate the War Powers Resolution. 70 Similarly, members of Congress must also have standing. 71 Likewise, the courts have dismissed Congressional members' suits for lacking standing, even claims of standing based on stewardship of taxpayer dollars. 72 Although often lacking standing and thereby access to the courts, members of Congress also have access to Congressional fora to disagree with military action which they should utilize rather than the courts. 73 Moreover, the courts will typically find that Congress cannot litigate the War Powers Resolution. 74

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.