Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

“Substantially” is NOT a term of art, so you should avoid defining it in a limiting fashion.

Arkush ’2 [David; January 1; J.D. Candidate at Harvard Law School; Harvard Civil Rights-Civil Liberties Law Review, “Preserving "Catalyst" Attorneys' Fees Under the Freedom of Information Act in the Wake of Buckhannon Board and Care Home v. West Virginia Department of Health and Human Resources,” vol. 37, p. 151]

Since the Supreme Court appears to have emphasized the classification in Buckhannon,(FN96) plaintiffs may find it useful or necessary to discuss whether "substantially prevail" is a legal term of art. The only clear consequence of classification as a "legal term of art" is that courts may be more likely to consult Black's Law Dictionary to define such words. The Buckhannon Court declared "prevailing party" a term of art and seems to have relied heavily on the 1997 edition of Black's, which defined the phrase as a "party in whose favor judgment is rendered."(FN97) Justice Scalia's concurrence similarly emphasized the special status of the term "prevailing party," writing, "[w]ords that have acquired a specialized meaning in the legal context must be accorded their legal meaning."(FN98)

Plaintiffs should argue that the term "substantially prevail" is not a term of art because if considered a term of art, resort to Black's 7th produces a definition of "prevail" that could be interpreted adversely to plaintiffs.(FN99) It is commonly accepted that words that are not legal terms of art should be accorded their ordinary, not their legal, meaning,(FN100) and ordinary-usage dictionaries provide FOIA fee claimants with helpful arguments. The Supreme Court has already found favorable, temporally relevant definitions of the word "substantially" in ordinary dictionaries:

"[S]ubstantially" suggests "considerable" or "specified to a large degree." See Webster's Third New International Dictionary 2280 (1976) (defining "substantially" as "in a substantial manner" and "substantial" as "considerable in amount, value, or worth" and "being that specified to a large degree or in the main"); see also 17 Oxford English Dictionary 66-67 (2d ed. 1989) ("substantial": "[r]elating to or proceeding from the essence of a thing; essential"; "of ample or considerable amount, quantity or dimensions").(FN101)

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.