Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

U.S. law treats MOUs as binding treaty obligations concluded by the executive

Barrett ’20 [Jill; 2020; Visiting Reader in the School of Law at Queen Mary University of London; and Robert Beckman, Emeritus Professor of Law at the National University of Singapore; Handbook on Good Treaty Practice, p. 105]

The Name of the Document Does Not Determine its Legal Status

A document which meets the legal criteria for being a treaty is a treaty, whatever its particular designation. No matter how non-binding the title sounds, if the content and context make clear that it is governed by international law, it may be a treaty. Conversely, a document could be entitled ‘treaty’ or ‘agreement’, but if it is evident from its contents or context that it is not governed by international law, it is not a treaty. This can make the task of distinguishing treaties from non-binding international instruments difficult. The document signed by the Foreign Minister of Bahrain which was interpreted by the ICJ as a binding agreement to take the dispute with Qatar to the ICJ, was called ‘Minutes’. Minutes of meetings do not usually have treaty status, but if an internationally binding agreement is entered into at the meeting, the record of the meeting could bind the parties.

The title ‘MOU’ is particularly apt to cause confusion. In the practice of many States, this title is used only for instruments which they consider to be political rather than legal. The practice of some States on this point is so consistent that the use of the title MOU may be taken as an indication of their intention that the instrument not be governed by international law. For example, Australia, Canada, New Zealand and the UK and many other States follow the same practice in this regard. However, in the practice of some other States, the title MOU is used for agreements which are treaties under international law, but which are classified for domestic law purposes as executive agreements (meaning that the approval of the legislature is not required). The United States, for example, follows this practice. When States with different practices conclude an MOU, it may be a treaty or it may not. Unsurprisingly, perhaps, some States appear to have no consistent practice, using the term MOU without regard to whether or not the document is intended to be a treaty. Some, such as New Zealand, seek to avoid using the title MOU at all because of the confusion it has generated.64

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.