Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

“Increase” must be on net.

McGuffey ’20 [Carroll; Summer; partner at Troutman Pepper Hamilton Sanders LLP; Natural Resources & Environment, “Reforming New Source Review: What Project Emissions Accounting Really Means, and Why It Should Survive,” p. 37]

The debate over how to count changes in emissions when determining NSR applicability is as old as the program itself. The CAA requires permitting for any “increase” in emissions, 42 U.S.C. §§ 7411, 7475, 7479, but it does not define the word “increase,” leaving room for interpretation. Such ambiguity leaves EPA in charge of deciding how sources must determine whether an “increase” will occur. New York, 413 F.3d at 22-24. In fact, a different dispute over the ambiguities in the very same statutory provision resulted in the Supreme Court's now famous (or infamous) Chevron decision on agency deference. Chevron U.S.A., Inc. v. Natural Res. Def. Council, 467 U.S. 837, 865 (1984) (concluding that the EPA's method of calculating emissions is a reasonable policy choice).

In an attempt to define the ambiguous word “increase,” EPA has adopted increasingly complex regulations, but those rules have consistently maintained that source owners must be allowed to consider the overall “net effect” of a project on the stationary source as a whole. This idea has taken on many names and forms over time--referred to variously as the “bubble concept,” “contemporaneous netting,” “project netting,” and now “Project Emissions Accounting.” The only debate has been in deciding what rules are needed to right-size the NSR permitting program so that permits are required only for those projects that truly warrant such review.

No one can predict with any certainty how the D.C. Circuit will receive PEA. However, the D.C. Circuit already decided long ago that the CAA allows EPA significant discretion in deciding how sources should calculate emissions increases and decreases in applying NSR permitting requirements.

The issue of whether and how to count multiple changes in emissions under NSR arose in the context of legal challenges to EPA's 1978 NSR rules. Alabama Power Co. v. Costle, 636 F.2d 323, 399-403 (D.C. Cir. 1980). In that lengthy opinion, specifically the portion authored by Judge Wilkey, the court recognized that there were two logical ways to interpret the word “increase” in the statute--a source must either determine the “net effect” or count only increases and ignore decreases.

The court resoundingly rejected the idea that decreases should be ignored, calling the idea “unreasonable and contrary to the expressed purposes of the [Act].” Instead, the court decided that the statute requires EPA to “look at any change proposed for a plant, and decide whether the net effect of all the steps involved in that change is to increase the emission of any air pollutant [;] this is commonly termed the ‘bubble’ concept.” Id. at 401 (emphasis added). To explain its reasoning, the court noted that “[t]he bubble concept is precisely suited to preserve air quality within a framework that allows cost-efficient, flexible planning for industrial expansion and improvement.” Id. at 402.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.