“With” requires American action.
Hartz ’18 [Harris; August 29; Court of Appeals Judge on the Tenth Circuit, dissenting; Westlaw, “United States v. Durham,” 902 F.3d 1180]
The panel opinion suggests that the text of the Commerce Clause indicates that power under the Foreign Commerce Clause exceeds that under the Interstate Commerce Clause. See Maj. Op. at 1201–02. It notes that the Clause speaks of commerce “with foreign Nations” but “among the several States.” But the difference in prepositions indicates the opposite. If the Clause permitted regulation of commerce “among foreign nations”—so that the two clauses used the same preposition—then Congress would be empowered to regulate commerce among France, England, and Italy, even if the United States were not involved at all. Thus, use of the preposition with instead of the preposition among obviously limits the extent of the Foreign Commerce Clause. See Colangelo supra at 970–71 (explaining the difference between the uses of the two prepositions in the Commerce Clause).7