Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

‘With’ requires involving NATO in the creation of the plan

Colangelo ’10 [Anthony; September; Assistant Professor of Law, SMU Dedman School of Law; “ARTICLE: THE FOREIGN COMMERCE CLAUSE,” Virginia Law Review, 96 Va. L. Rev. 949]

It was precisely this general, national regulatory power that saved application of the federal Controlled Substances Act ("CSA") to homegrown medical-use marijuana in the Court's 2005 decision Gonzales v. Raich, 128 and that has constitutionally justified numerous federal laws designed to prevent various races to the bottom "among" the states. 129 The Foreign Commerce Clause contains no equivalent, globally-encompassing authority to regulate "among" foreign nations, only the power to regulate commerce "with" them. 130 The difference between the power to regulate among members of the domestic system, but only with members of the international system, suggests that Congress has no more power to regulate inside foreign nations than it has inside the several states.131 Indeed, as Section B explains in more depth - and [*974] contrary to leading lower-court decisions - this textual difference actually deprives Congress of some of the more sweeping regulatory powers abroad that it enjoys at home.132 To preview the argument, Congress cannot independently create comprehensive global regulatory schemes over international markets or prevent races to the bottom among the world's nations the same way it can create comprehensive national regulatory schemes over domestic markets and prevent races to the bottom among the states. Because Congress lacks primary authority to create such global schemes, it cannot claim a derivative authority under the Necessary and Proper Clause to reach local foreign conduct that threatens to undercut those schemes the same way it can reach local intrastate conduct to [*975] effectuate regulation "among the several States."133 Rather, for Congress to regulate local foreign conduct pursuant to a comprehensive international regulatory scheme, that scheme must be created "with foreign Nations."134 In this sense, the word "with" contemplates agreement or cooperation with foreign nations in establishing the scheme, without which Congress cannot extend U.S. law over local foreign conduct to effectuate that scheme.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.