Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

“Defense-only” interps badly misunderstand NATO’s evolution over time---Article 5 is irrelevant---US coop with NATO on emerging tech is necessarily political, not military

Weaver ’21 [John Michael; 2021; Associate Professor of Intelligence Analysis at York College of Pennsylvania (USA), a retired DOD civilian from the United States' Intelligence Community, and has served as an officer in the US Army (retiring at the rank of lieutenant colonel); NATO in Contemporary Times: Purpose, Relevance, Future, Palgrave Macmillan]

The political aspects that the NATO diplomats bring is essential for the success of the Alliance; diplomacy itself is an instrument of power and one that is critical as a "soft" component to bring about influence in the world (Weaver 2018a; Weaver 2018b; Weaver 2020; Weaver and Pomeroy 2018; Weaver and Pomeroy 2019, 2020; Weaver and Johnson 2020). To be effective and to remain relevant, it must look to clearly articulate objectives to NATO commanders at all levels (Kruger-Klausen and Odgaard 2014). The Alliance also helps enable nations like the United States to leverage others to minimize the burden of being the sole bearer of the problem while adding legitimacy to the mission (Jakobsen 2014, 5). What's more, is that NATO can bring together a variegated mix of capabilities that single nations might lack (Jakobsen 2014, 60).

Similar to the United Nations, it is frequently quite challenging to come to commonly acceptable terms due to the disparate mix of nations each with their own agendas to help maintain their relevancy and position on the global stage (Geoana 2020). It is not easy to realize consensus and when looking at divides between individual nations, like the United States and France (cultural differences), Greece, and Turkey (a history of hostility), and divisions between larger members like the United States and the European Union, the United Kingdom and the European Union (over Brexit), and many NATO nations and Turkey (due to Turkey's move towards a closer relationship with Russia), and one can quickly see how challenges abound for the political leaders of the Alliance.

That stated, diversity is often a good thing. It brings in new experiences, leads to better problem-solving, and offers additional perspectives. 

Working in diverse environments also promotes creativity and opens up the dialogue to innovative ideas. Looking at problems through different cultural lenses can add value, might assist in conflict avoidance, and even lead to greater legitimacy especially if there is a move afoot to gravitate toward the direction of armed conflict or intervention. The addition of more members and the collaboration of countries in recent years and into the future will further increase NATO's diversity, give NATO leaders more cultural lenses to look through, and help avoid groupthink.

Because NATO is a political organization first and foremost, the civilians that serve as the head of this Alliance are probably going to be more inclined to look to diplomatic efforts to help avoid the employment of military forces. NATO Deputy Secretary General Mircea Geoana (2020) underscored the importance of NATO's political influence in a panel discussion when he underscored the necessity of NATO to expand its political influence while trying to limit formal expansion to leverage (1) that no other alliance has a greater sharing of values than NATO, that (2) NATO countries possess 50% of the world's Gross Domestic Product (GDP), and that the Alliance holds over 50% of the world's military power. This is important because NATO (the NATO Command Structure or NCS) has few permanent military forces itself and this is a weakness. NATO depends on member countries to contribute military forces, if and when needed. While NATO does maintain some military equipment, most equipment is contributed by member nations to support their military personnel (NATO Troop Contributions 2018). This can directly correlate into issue resolution for NATO as a whole and reduce the costs associated with member nation contributions of troops at the individual nation level.

Another weakness is that NATO heavily relies on member contributions for funding, and it is not entirely balanced. Additionally, NATO provides political and financial oversight for any jointly funded projects among member nations. Some countries have to spend more in order to develop additional capabilities for which the Alliance asks (cyber, communications, stand-off weapons, etc.) (NATO Funding, n.d.). NATO also relies on the United States for some essential operations, such as ballistic missile defense, airborne electronic warfare, and air-to-air refueling. However, the United Kingdom, France, and Germany contribute more than 50 percent of the non-defense spending (NATO Funding, n.d.).

That stated, each country will probably not see the solution that they would like brought to fruition that they would prefer. Consensus is rarely possible when multiple parties from diverse backgrounds are involved. Compromise will likely occur with each NATO member advocating for their preferred course of action, and the actual decision becoming "watered down" because not all nations will agree with individual member recommendations. The ability of NATO members to keep an open mind, work together, and compromise is vital for NATO's success.

NATO leaders will have to continue to adapt to a quickly changing world. Having strong allies outside of NATO aids in foreign policy negotiations and helps reduce the risk of military conflict and this is an opportunity. The member nations will have to ensure they can form agreements within NATO and with its partners. For NATO to remain relevant, especially in the context of its burgeoning 30 member states, Alliance members will have to put aside differences and look to a utilitarian approach to solving problems at the top for this supranational organization to remain relevant in the future.

There are threats. When turning to cyber, issues regarding cyber network operations are burgeoning and becoming more problematic (Weaver and Johnson 2020). Cyberspace has been designated as its own military domain, separate from land, air, sea, and space (NATO 2020). The Deputy Secretary General stated that NATO agreed to create a Cyberspace Operations Center in the military command structure (NATO 2020); what is needed is a clear understanding of the effects that the NATO SECGEN wants to achieve so that it can be task organized accordingly. It has also been noted that some actors have been exploiting the COVID-19 crisis, and there has been an increase in malevolent cyber activity since it began (NATO 2020). NATO will have to explore its interpretation of whether or not cyber attacks constitute an Article 5 attack. Geoana (2020), also underscored the challenges confronting the expansion of cyber to include artificial intelligence and quantum computing in the years ahead. Moreover, NATO will have to come to understand advanced persistent threats (APTs), the Internet of Things (IOT), the use of "deep fakes" and more when looking at the topic of cyber (Weaver and Johnson 2020).

To achieve success will require partnerships and synchronization to remain relevant. More pointedly, NATO political leaders will have to work with military planners (Kruger-Klausen and Odgaard 2014). The threats facing the Alliance members have drastically changed since it was founded. A military attack from a hostile actor is less likely to occur now than during the Cold War, but Russia still is a concern (Geoana 2020). Other challenges are more in the realms of terrorism, and nuclear proliferation (Geoana 2020). NATO leaders will have to form a clear vision and a formidable strategy to remain relevant to survive (Shea 2014, 41).

Moving forward, NATO will have many challenges. More to the point, NATO Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg has underscored three points. These include (1) remaining strong as an Alliance to remain formidable and keep its edge, (2) looking at how NATO can enhance its political influence even though there will be disagreement at times among NATO member nations, and (3) looking to how NATO becomes even more relevant globally without expanding its formal membership (Geoana 2020). Direction and guidance must be clear. The Alliance must also come to terms with the political realities of what is truly possible and knowing what exceeds the political will of member countries. Once this is understood, NATO as a political entity, can move forward with identifying the ways, means, and ends necessary to achieve what the Alliance wants to accomplish. Finally, NATO should turn to its Emerging Security Challenges Division (ESCD) to look at future threats to the Alliance and determine the best way forward to address these (ESCD, n.d.).

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.