Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Focusing NATO’s output on force plans and strategy best improves interoperability and cohesion---otherwise, spending is meaningless.

Cappello 8-13-18, a former B-1B pilot, served as the Air Force Attaché to the U.S. Embassies in Belgrade and Tel Aviv, and is currently a senior fellow at the Foundation for Defense of Democracies, (John, August 13th, 2018, “NATO’s Two Percent and Burden Sharing”, https://www.realcleardefense.com/articles/2018/08/13/natos_two_percent_and_burden_sharing_113713.html?utm_campaign=755f44acff-EMAIL_CAMPAIGN_2018_08_12_12_56&utm_medium=email&utm_source=RC%20Defense%20Morning%20Recon&utm_term=0_694f73a8dc-755f44acff-81835773)

NATO Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg, however, noted how all allies have halted cuts to their defense budgets and have begun implementing plans to their defense budgets to two percent of their respective GDPs, with a majority planning to reach that goal by . While Stoltenberg credited President Trump with delivering a “clear message” on burden sharing, this debate misses an important point. Simply spending more does not equate with actual burden sharing.

According to NATO’s , collective defense, crisis management, and collective security are the alliance’s core tasks. These missions require capable, mobile, and interoperable forces. Real burden sharing would require every ally to contribute forces ready to deploy for such missions.  

alone fails to measure real military capability, let alone its use on the alliance’s behalf. Take the cases of and Greece. In , Greece spent 2.32 percent of its GDP on defense, while Denmark spent only 1.17 percent. Using the 2 percent goal as a benchmark, one would, therefore, conclude that Greece is a model NATO partner while Denmark is a free rider “taking advantage of the United States.” These numbers, however, do not accurately illustrate how these two nations actually share the burden.

From to and Afghanistan to Iraq, the Danish military is actively deployed in support of NATO’s out-of-area missions. Although it spends more than 2 percent of its GDP on defense, Greece contributed none of its 21,500 to NATO missions ().

The Danish and Greek militaries are not outliers—additional shows similar discrepancies among other nations as well. The point is, NATO’s needs are not met by spending 2 percent of GDP alone. Members’ contributions to NATO missions of capable, ready, and deployable forces are what actually matter.

This was made clear once again, when three Czech soldiers serving with NATO's Resolute Support mission were killed in Afghanistan by a suicide bomber. The Czech Republic had recently approved a to deploy 390 soldiers in Afghanistan through 2020, up from the current 230. While the Czech Republic has not yet met the two percent of GDP spending goal, it does participate in NATO missions fighting, dying and the risk alongside their deployed counterparts.

While allies should meet their two percent of GDP commitment, they should also spend that money more wisely, focusing on concrete investments to eliminate capability shortfalls. For example, meeting the related pledge to spend 20 percent of defense budgets on equipment (as opposed to salaries or operations) will facilitate the development of cutting-edge weapon systems that are capable, deployable and interoperable.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.