Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← SearchMichigan2022Disadvantage
Opening Word document…

NATO cyberoperations exacerbate distrust between members – cyber exploits require secrecy which results in allied deconfliction.

Jacobsen 21 [Jeppe T. Jacobsen is a Ph.D. candidate at the Danish Institute for International Studies and the Center for War Studies at the University of Southern Denmark. His primary focus is U.S. cyber armament, its motivation and consequences to international security. Jacobsen worked as cyber coordinator at the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Denmark where he coordinated Denmark’s cyber diplomacy. ; “Cyber offense in NATO: challenges and opportunities”; International Affairs; May 10, 2021; https://academic.oup.com/ia/article-abstract/97/3/703/6205395]//eleanor

The third challenge to the integration of cyber effects in NATO operations relates to a well-known military concept, deconfliction. The coordination by allies and military units of their efforts to avoid confliction, between for example an air operation and a special forces operation in the same area, is a central element in every military campaign. Deconfliction is all about openness and communication between allied partners. But in cyberspace, deconfliction comes with several difficulties. At the core of these difficulties is the fact that the tools and techniques that produce cyber effects—which are often also used and heavily depended on for intelligence collection—are developed in secret and must stay secret until the effect is achieved. If the IT vulnerabilities and exploits are known, vendors or adversaries can fix or replace the software and thereby render the effect impossible to achieve.39 In an alliance not known for sufficient mutual trust among members to share intelligence,40 there is little indication that allies will become more open about the cyber tools and techniques they currently have at their disposal. The request-based model is the result of that lack of trust. And the unwillingness to share cyber intelligence seriously challenges NATO’s ambition to use CYOC to facilitate information-sharing to increase situational awareness and thereby achieve the ‘cyber readiness’ and ‘cyber resiliency’ that NATO Deputy Secretary-General Mircea Geoană hopes to attain.41 Furthermore, lack of coordination and discussion about the use of military cyber capabilities, both internally in each state and among allies, can have negative implications for intelligence activities and general network security. A conventional military decision to deliver cyber effects is rarely concerned with maintaining access and staying secret after an effect is achieved. Even though it is customary to try to obscure the vulnerabilities that are being exploited, it is difficult to ensure that those operating the targeted system or third-party network analysts do not identify and fix the vulnerabilities in, for example, commercial products used all over the world. Thus, military plans to engage other state entities need to weigh the benefit of delivering cyber effects against the risk of losing intelligence capacity, as well as the risk that other actors (allies, corporations, adversaries, criminals, etc.) will use the same exploits against oneself. In other words, there is a conflict of interest between attack, intelligence collection and internal defence in each NATO member state.42 The desire of the US Cyber Command to become more independent from the National Security Agency (NSA) is precisely an attempt to gain a stronger voice when the US government assesses whether a vulnerability should be disclosed to vendors, retained for intelligence purposes or used to deliver ‘loud’ cyber effects.43 The risk of confliction among allies arises from the fact that a similar assessment procedure does not exist across NATO. As conversations with several national representatives at the CDC reveal, such a procedure is unlikely to be agreed upon owing to the different perspectives on offence, defence and espionage in cyberspace currently prevailing among member states.44 If the Netherlands, for example, offers to deliver a ‘loud’ cyber effect in a NATO operation, British or American intelligence operations could end up being disturbed because they rely on the same vulnerabilities which—when used in military operations—risk being exposed and subsequently fixed.45 When deploying ‘loud’ cyber effects, malicious actors such as criminals are also given the opportunity to identify and exploit the same vulnerabilities in unpatched systems in allied countries. The ransomware incidents known as WannaCry and NotPetya are examples of the damage that can emerge from government exploits becoming publicly available—even though the specific vulnerabilities were already patched by Microsoft and updates released to supported systems.46 In short, there is a dilemma both internally, between intelligence agencies and the military, and externally, between allies. While it is difficult to do much about the latter, the internal power dynamics in most states, with the intelligence agencies as the primary cyber actors, are likely to limit the willingness of most states to deliver military cyber effects—whether offensive or defensive—when CYOC makes requests. They also limit the willingness to share cyber threat information across the alliance through CYOC. This section has pointed to three characteristics about cyberspace that limit the integration of cyber effects in NATO operations. In a complex and constantly changing cyberspace, it continues to be difficult to develop and maintain sophisticated exploits for targeted cyber effects. This is especially the case if the cyber effects are requested for a specific time and place in order to guarantee operational success, and if they simultaneously have to be verifiable and conform to international legal principles. Neither the member states, which face an internal dilemma between attack, intelligence collection and defence in cyberspace, nor the NATO commander, who will prefer to control the capabilities used, are likely to feel sufficiently confident about the targeted or highly integrated cyber effects to choose that option if other capabilities are available.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.