Confronting China causes overstretch and escalation spirals.
Depetris 8-18-2020, fellow at Defense Priorities and a columnist at the Washington Examiner. (Daniel Depetris, "China isn't the Soviet Union, and the US needs to find a different way to compete", Business Insider, https://www.businessinsider.com/us-needs-to-find-different-way-to-compete-with-china-2020-8)
Unfortunately, simplifying China as a modern-day Soviet Union misdiagnoses the problem and leads to a faulty cure. Combatting Chinese power everywhere and anywhere will exhaust the US, deplete its resources and weaken US power over the long-term.
For nearly 30 years, the Washington foreign policy establishment has gotten used to the United States being the paramount power in the global system. But this is no longer the world we are living in.
While the US is still the world's largest military and economic power, China is a close second. Since the dawn of the century, the Chinese economy has increased from $1.2 trillion to $14.3 trillion. China's exponential growth has allowed the CCP to invest additional resources into building up a capable, modernized and proficient military, including a world-class navy.
With its frequent forays into Japanese waters, flyovers across the Taiwan Straits, and trillion-dollar Belt and Road initiative in Eurasia, China is doing what rising powers have done throughout history — translating its economic success into geopolitical leverage. A US policy of containment would have the adverse affect of heightening the sense of alarmism in Beijing.
The U.S. can and should compete with China economically. But it should do so responsibly in order to prevent this competitiveness from drifting into military affairs.
A decoupling from China, Washington's largest trading partner outside of North America, is not a realistic proposal. A complete severance of economic ties will produce unprecedented pain for middle-class Americans and roil the international financial system.
A military-to-military showdown, meanwhile, simply entrenches hardline positions in both Washington and Beijing and lessens the credibility of those who call for dialogue and deescalation.