Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

1NC --- Solvency

Creating intersectional movements and policy is the only way to address ableist and discriminatory policy

Jampel, 18 (Catherine Jampel), “Intersections of disability justice, racial justice and environmental justice.” Environmental Sociology. . Accessed 7-22-2021. ALS

Philosopher Anna Carastathis (2013) recuperates one of Crenshaw’s early metaphors in order to illustrate this point. Crenshaw’s (1989) metaphor of a basement with a trap door illustrates how single-axis or limited-axis movements may fail people facing multiple systems of oppression. By system of oppression, I mean historical and institutionalized patterns that disadvantage a particular group of people based on their social identity. Systems of oppression include racism, sexism, heterosexism, ableism and so forth. In the ‘basement’ metaphor, ‘all people who are disadvantaged on the basis of race, sex, class, sexual preference, age, and/or physical ability’ occupy a basement with ‘those on the bottom being disadvantaged by the full array of factors, up to the very top, where the heads of those disadvantaged by a singular factor brush up against the ceiling’ (Crenshaw 1989, 151). In Crenshaw’s initial work on intersectionality, which examined why Black women facing discrimination did not have legal recourse, White women and Black men could say they would be out of the basement ‘but for’ the ceiling. However, Black women faced two ‘but fors’ – racism and sexism – and became legally invisible. Truly intersectional work aims to address all of the systems of oppression that might leave someone in the metaphorical basement. The ‘Applications: bringing intersectionality and disability justice to EJ work’ section of this paper will include examples of how EJ work can avoid perpetuating ableism, the system that oppresses people with nonnormative bodies and minds.

Understandings ableism in environmental justice is a precursor to policy action

Jampel, 18 (Catherine Jampel), “Intersections of disability justice, racial justice and environmental justice.” Environmental Sociology. . Accessed 7-22-2021. ALS

Analytical strategy for explanation: deepening understanding of EJ issues by critically attending to disability Attention to multiple systems of oppression and axes of social difference also enhances the capacity for explaining a phenomenon, in this case environmental injustice. Here, I turn to three ways in which thinking about ableism and disablement can enrich explanations of environmental injustice. Differential exposure and vulnerability – the traffic crash Exposure. People with disabilities are specifically exposed to and vulnerable to environmental injustice as a result of ableism. Just as people occupying marginalized race and class positions are geographically segregated, so are people with disabilities more likely than those without to be geographically segregated, unemployed or underemployed, and poor (Russell 1998; Hemingway and Priestley 2006). This makes people with disabilities more likely to live in areas with disproportionate burden of environmental bads, such as near current or legacy factory sites. Moreover, those most likely to be subject to and bear the greatest burdens of environmental injustice often occupy multiple marginalized social locations. Scholars have demonstrated this with respect to disability, gender and race in the case of Hurricane Katrina. Hurricane Katrina, established in the academic literature as an issue of EJ (Sze 2006), climate justice (Schlosberg and Collins 2014) and racial justice (Elliott and Pais 2006), illustrates how disability status contributed to the lived experiences of people in New Orleans, and why Hurricane Katrina also presented issues of disability justice (Finger 2005; NCD 2005). Public health researchers found that those, who did not evacuate ‘lacked public transportation, misjudged the storm, were limited by their own or a family member’s physical disability, and were more likely to be lifetime New Orleans residents’ (Brodie et al. 2006, 1407). Among those who were evacuated, 27,000 people moved from the Superdome in New Orleans to the Astrodome in Houston, Texas. Some of the arrivals had lost their mobility devices and, until donated wheelchairs arrived, had difficultly accessing the restrooms in the large arena, while other arrivals who see and hear with different strategies than typically seeing and hearing people had to adapt to the new environment until accessibility was addressed after several days (Bloodworth et al. 2007). Lack of access to disability-aware spaces and underestimation of disability-specific supplies meant that evacuees were further harmed even after leaving the hurricane area. Evacuation exacerbated previous chronic health conditions as well given the extent to which lowincome people relied on public hospitals decimated by the storm (Brodie et al. 2006). A disability justice framework understands that it is not people with disabilities who are ‘unprepared’ but rather ableism that has contributed to a larger system that has failed them and their families (Fenney Salkeld 2016; Kim 2016, 198–212). Likewise, Hurricane Katrina created conditions for further disablement. For example, demographer Narayan Sastry and economist Jesse Gregory (2013) explicitly focus on disability as an ‘effect’ of Hurricane Katrina – making disability the dependent variable and accounting for age, race and sex as independent variables. Their analysis of data from the American Community Survey revealed that the increase in disability in New Orleans was disproportionately concentrated among young and middle-aged Black women, with the young faring the worst. Sastry and Gregory draw on the extant literature to review the potential factors contributing to multiple marginalization – young black women were caught at the intersection of race, gender and age in such a way that adverse outcomes compounded. As Black people, they were more likely to live in dwellings and communities that suffered the most damage, leading to loss of property and neighborhood ties. As women, they were more likely to be left with children after households broke up, and the difficulties children in their care faced post-hurricane may have been sources of stress and consequent mental health effects. As young people, new mental and physical impairments were more 6 C. JAMPEL Downloaded by [66.189.72.133] at 06:07 11 January 2018 disabling, the researchers speculated, because of their effects on ability to work, having younger children not as easily able to help with daily tasks such as shopping, and more limited access to financial resources. In their explanation, the researchers imply a contextual model of disablement as a result of historical processes.

Environmental impacts are uniquely magnified against disabled bodies – only a critical intersectional lens towards political processes can identify vulnerability

Jampel, 18 (Catherine Jampel), “Intersections of disability justice, racial justice and environmental justice.” Environmental Sociology. . Accessed 7-22-2021. ALS

Vulnerability. People whose bodies diverge from the ‘normal’ or ‘standard’ may face greater exposure to environmental injustice than other people. For some people, their bodily differences may also make them especially vulnerable to the effects of certain environmentally unjust conditions. For example, people who are immunosuppressed or have biological variations such as ‘slow acetylation’ bear a greater burden when exposed to air pollution, pesticides, industrial chemicals and a host of other toxic trespasses, a phrase Sandra Steingraber (2010, 279) uses to describe involuntary human exposure to a pollutant. As she explains, people who are slow acetylators have low levels of the enzymes that detoxify aromatic amines, a class of organic compounds used in pesticides and strongly associated with bladder cancer (2010, 268). Slow(er) acetylation becomes a disability when high level of aromatic amine exposure is part of society and culture. Biological variation compounded with racialized, classed and gendered exposures to toxics demonstrates how disability status ends up being created and then exacerbated through a political– economic context. As mainstream discourses shape an understanding through which the most ‘vulnerable populations’ are ‘expected’ to be further impaired or harmed (Fjord 2007), a critical and intersectional EJ lens can direct attention toward the political processes that lead to unnecessary occupational and everyday exposures to compounds such as the aromatic amines used in dyes, pesticides and plastics.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.