First strike postures cause rapid escalation and great power conflicts
Mendenhall 19 [Elizabeth Mendenhall, Dr. Elizabeth Mendenhall has a Ph.D. in International Relations from Johns Hopkins University and is now an assistant professor at the University of Rhode Island's Department of Marine Affairs. She teaches International Ocean Governance in Marine Affairs, and has a (limited) joint appointment with Political Science. Her research centers on the ocean governance regime, especially the Law of the Sea Convention. January 2019, accessed on 7-2-2022, Journal of Military Strategies, "Fluid Foundations: Ocean Transparency, Submarine Opacity, and Strategic Nuclear Stability", mimou]
Force structure changes occur slowly, and countries reacting to transparency may pursue interim strategies for achieving nuclear deterrence. One means of making a retaliatory strike secure is to launch the weapons before the first strike hits. In the early Cold War, American strategists proposed adopting a “launch on warning” posture until a survivable force – such as mobile ICBMs – could be built and deployed.155 The adoption of such a posture would in itself be a negative development for strategic nuclear stability; “launch on warning” is understood to significantly increase the risk of accidental war.156 If countries like the United States and Russia adopt this posture, China, India, and Pakistan are likely to do the same.157 A “launch on warning” posture would be even more dangerous in South Asia.158 The possibility of an effective first strike by the United States could destabilize great power politics by encouraging such risky strategic postures, and even military pre-emption.159 The best way to “de-alert” from a dangerous “launch on warning” posture is to assign the function of retaliation to a completely survivable force.160