Sudden boost in transparency tech destabilizes nuclear weapons – increases launch on warning and instability
Mendenhall 19 [Elizabeth Mendenhall, Dr. Elizabeth Mendenhall has a Ph.D. in International Relations from Johns Hopkins University and is now an assistant professor at the University of Rhode Island's Department of Marine Affairs. She teaches International Ocean Governance in Marine Affairs, and has a (limited) joint appointment with Political Science. Her research centers on the ocean governance regime, especially the Law of the Sea Convention. January 2019, accessed on 7-2-2022, Journal of Military Strategies, "Fluid Foundations: Ocean Transparency, Submarine Opacity, and Strategic Nuclear Stability", mimou]
Transparency does not have to be synoptic to make submarines vulnerable. The small number of SSBNs each national military has on patrol, and the even smaller number of submarine bases, means that sensing technologies can achieve functional transparency before they achieve global-scale transparency. 161 AUV platforms in particular could pick up a submarine as it exits its base or transits maritime chokepoints, and then track its course automatically.162 This situation, where a state locates all of its rival’s SSBNs today, but may not be able to keep track of them tomorrow, is particularly destabilizing. A closing window of first strike opportunity increases crisis instability, which is why forces that are always invulnerable are best for stability.163 There are many other possible ways that military actors may respond to increasing ocean transparency. The isolated, open-ocean patrols that formerly hid SSBNs safely under the surface may become a thing of the past. The bastion strategy could be adopted by all major nuclear powers, such that SSBNs are kept in noisy, covered, or well-defended areas. Large swarms of AUVs may travel in convoys around SSBNs to disrupt localization by acoustic or non-acoustic measures. Fear of transparency could lead vulnerable nuclear powers to target communications nodes that enable networked sensing, or develop techniques to trawl AUVs out of certain areas. Attempts to sustain survivability could be relatively simple – such as investing in mobile ICBMs or adopting “launch on warning” postures – or complex, involving ASW measures and counter-measures without one having a clear advantage. Any of these scenarios represent a significant risk of instability. Conclusion If ocean transparency made nuclear strategic submarines more detectable, locatable, and targetable, the military and political implications would be significant. Yet the topic of SSBN vulnerability is “virtually taboo” in the US Navy’s public documents. 164 A culture of complacency has set in regarding the role and missions of SSBNs, such that submariners are poorly equipped to adjust to potentially novel operational realities. 165 Other countries are walking the same path: the planned development of SSBNs by India and Pakistan is driven by a judgment about their superior and durable survivability. 166 This paper challenges the assumption that extrapolations from the past can serve as reliable guides for the future. Specifically, the security of second-strike capabilities, and therefore the assurance of mutual destruction, rests on fluid material foundations. Whether the potential obsolescence of “hiding” technologies occurs as a slow erosion of usefulness, or an avalanche of illumination, could have serious implications for nuclear strategic stability. The possibility of, and reactions to, ocean transparency present a challenge for the prevailing arms control regime. The force structures created and shaped by existing arms control treaties assume the superior survivability of SSBNs as the foundation of nuclear deterrence. If transparency were to arrive as a “technological surprise,” this feature of the regime sets the stage for instability.167 The responses to transparency described in the final section each have negative implications for the existing arms control regime. Without invulnerability, nuclear states may pursue a “safety in numbers” approach to achieving a secure second strike, which would require a substantial buildup in weaponry. The pursuit of “launch on warning” postures conflicts with the arms control agenda of “lengthening the fuse.”168 If “mutually assured destruction” were abandoned wholesale, the possible return to a “war strategism” approach that sees nuclear weapons as usable would be especially detrimental to the arms control agenda. An arms control regime that accounts for the possible erosion of transparency might replicate the Treaty on Open Skies, which regulates the frequency and resolution of aircraft surveillance.169 This strategy would entail rebuilding opacity by treaty where it may be undermined by technology.