U.S sub detection capabilities cause Russian prolif, and destabilizing escalation scenarios
Kattan 21 [Ari Kattan, Ari Kattan is a policy analyst at Science Applications International Corporation (SAIC), where he supports the DefenseScience Board. The views expressed here are those of the author and do not necessarily represent the views of SAIC or itsgovernment clients., 08-15-2021, accessed on 7-2-2022, Center for Strategic and International Studies, "Emerging Submarine Detection Technologies and Implications for Strategic Stability", https://www.jstor.org/stable/resrep22545.9?seq=1 mimou]
The U.S.-Russia relationship is defined by Russian fear of its own weaknesses (economic, technological, etc.) and paranoia about U.S. and NATO threats to its security. Russia currently fears U.S. conventional superiority20 and has invested in capabilities and tactics to circumvent it.21 It is embarking on a modernization program for its nuclear weapons in part because it feels insecure about the survivability of its nuclear forces as the United States increases its progress on ballistic missile defense. If the United States were able to track Russian nuclear-armed submarines with increased confidence, it could exacerbate these Russian fears even more, causing Russia to respond in destabilizing ways. While it is true that Russia has never relied as much on submarine-based weapons as the United States has, the degradation of the survivability of Russia’s nuclear-armed submarines would likely cause Russia to compensate for this new vulnerability. This is especially true if continued advancements in precision strike make Russia’s air- and land-based nuclear forces more vulnerable. If Russia can no longer rely on hardening and concealment for survivability, they may double down on redundancy, producing and deploying larger numbers of nuclear weapons to complicate U.S. targeting and increase the odds that a retaliatory capability survives any U.S. first strike. This, in turn, could put the final nail in the coffin of arms control and lead to an arms race with the United States that drains resources, intensifies mistrust, and makes miscalculation more likely. In short, a significant U.S. advantage in submarine detection (which would likely develop in parallel with a U.S. advantage in remote sensing and precision strike capabilities in other domains) would likely be destabilizing due to Russian sensitivity over its technological inferiority. This could compel Russia not only to increase redundancy with a larger number of warheads, but to change the doctrine governing their use as well. It is possible that in an environment of degraded second-strike stability, Russia could move further towards a first-use doctrine to deter escalation and to avoid the “lose them or lose them” dilemma. China would likely be less sensitive to advancements in U.S. submarine detection capabilities for two reasons. First, China’s strategic relationship with the United States, at least currently, is not defined by an assumed need for parity but by a need for a minimum reprisal capability, which it believes it has and will continue to have in the future.22 It currently has a much smaller nuclear arsenal than the United States and relies on hardened and road-mobile land-based ICBMs for its retaliatory capability, which it believes is sufficient as long as it can hit the United States with just a few nuclear warheads, or even a single nuclear warhead.23 Second, China has not historically relied on SSBNs for its second-strike capability, and even as it begins deploying a credible sea-based nuclear deterrent for the first time,24 it recognizes that its submarines are less advanced and thus more vulnerable to ASW than U.S. submarines. Therefore, China will likely continue to rely on land-based nuclear forces.25 The remote sensing and precision strike revolution will certainly have implications for U.S.-China relations, but in the narrow hypothetical of U.S. superiority in submarine detection, China would be less concerned than Russia. They may, however, be sufficiently concerned that they decide to expand the size of their arsenal as a hedge. Overall, conditions under which the United States had a significant advantage in submarine detection could push some adversaries away from an assured retaliation nuclear posture and towards what Vipin Narang calls an asymmetric escalation nuclear posture.26 An asymmetric escalation nuclear posture entails threatening to use nuclear weapons first in a conflict to deter conflict and to prevent successful counterforce targeting by an adversary. If nations currently predisposed towards adopting assured retaliation postures no longer feel that the second-strike forces necessary for such a posture are secure, they may be forced to adopt asymmetric escalation postures.