Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Perception of autonomous subs is enough to trigger the link --- undermines confidence in second strike and triggers destabilization

Johnson 20 [James Johnson, James has a PhD in Politics and International Relations from the University of Leicester. He is the author of The US-China Military & Defense Relationship During the Obama Presidency. He is also a Postdoctoral Fellow at the James Martin Center for Nonproliferation. 4-16-2020, Taylor & Francis, "Artificial Intelligence, Drone Swarming and Escalation Risks in Future Warfare", https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/03071847.2020.1752026?scroll=top&needAccess=true&journalCode=rusi20 mimou]

Finally, in the maritime domain, UUVs, USVs and UAVs – supported by AI-enabled intra-swarm communication and ISR systems – could be deployed simultaneously in both offensive and defensive ASW operations to saturate an enemy’s defences and locate, disable and destroy its nuclear-armed or non-nuclear attack submarines.67 Tracking a submarine from a ship (or even from another submarine) is a challenging operation even in relatively benign conditions68 because of the stealth technology – especially minimal acoustic signatures – of modern diesel-electric submarines (SSKs) and SSBNs, along with the immense challenge of coordinating such an operation.69 While some experts do not expect a technically reliable and effective capability of this kind to be operational for at least a decade, others are more optimistic.70 From a tactical perspective, drone swarms would not need ocean-wide coverage (or full ocean transparency) to detect and track submarines effectively.71 According to British Rear Admiral John Gower, a relatively even spread of sensors might be sufficient for ‘a viable search and detection plan [to] be conceived for the open ocean’, requiring ‘high tens of thousands or low hundreds of thousands of UUVs’.72 Moreover, advances in mobile sensing platforms could enable drone swarms to locate submarines through chokepoints (or gateways) as they emerge from ports, and then to trail them autonomously.73 In this way, new iterations of machine-learning augmented UUVs and USVs might complement, and perhaps replace entirely, the traditional role of general-purpose SSBNs and manned surface vehicles in tracking and trailing submarines of adversaries at chokepoints, while simultaneously mounting sparsely distributed and mobile-distributed network system sensors on UUVs.74 Algorithm Warfare and Force Majeure Autonomous Weapons If a state views the credibility of its survivable nuclear weapons (especially nuclear-armed submarines) to be at risk, conventional capabilities such as drone swarms will likely have a destabilising effect at a strategic level.75 Thus, even if swarm sorties were not intended as (or indeed technically capable of) a disarming first strike, the perception alone of the feasibility of such an operation would be destabilising. Moreover, the speed of AI could put the defender at a distinct disadvantage, creating additional incentives to strike first (or pre-emptively) at technologically superior military rivals. Consequently, the less secure a state considers its second-strike capabilities to be, the more likely it is to countenance the use of autonomous systems within its nuclear weapons complex to bolster the survivability of its strategic forces. According to analyst Paul Scharre, ‘winning in swarm combat may depend on having the best algorithms to enable better coordination and faster reaction times, rather than simply the best platforms.76 Combining speed, persistence, scope, coordination and battlefield mass, AWS will offer states attractive asymmetric options to project military power within contested anti-access/area denial (A2/AD) zones.77 Enhanced by sophisticated machine-learning neural networks,78 China’s manned and unmanned drone teaming operations could potentially impede future US freedom of navigation operations in the South China Seas.79 Were China to infuse its cruise missiles and hypersonic glide capabilities with AI and autonomy, close-range encounters in the Taiwan Strait, and the East and South China Seas would become more complex, accident-prone and destabilising – at both a conventional and nuclear level.80 China is reportedly developing and deploying UUVs to bolster its underwater monitoring and antisubmarine capabilities, as part of a broader goal to establish an ‘underwater Great Wall’ to challenge US undersea military primacy.81 US AI-enhanced UUVs could, for example, potentially threaten both China’s nuclear ballistic and non-nuclear attack submarines.82 Thus, even if US UUVs were programmed only to threaten China’s non-nuclear (or non-strategic) attack submarine fleets, Chinese commanders might nonetheless fear that China’s nascent and relatively noisy and small (compared with US and Russian SSBNs) sea-based nuclear deterrent could be neutralised more easily.83

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.