Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Stability and confidence in second strike ensures MAD and deterrence --- the aff’s perception change is the ONLY chance for a U.S.-China War

Colby and Denmark 13

(Elbridge A. Colby, Robert M. Gates Senior Fellow at the Center for a New American Security, and Abraham M. Denmark, United States Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defense for East Asia, March 2013, “Nuclear Weapons and U.S.-China Relations: A Way Forward”, https://csis-prod.s3.amazonaws.com/s3fs-public/legacy_files/files/publication/130307_Colby_USChinaNuclear_Web.pdf)

To gain the benefits of strategic stability, the Working Group believes that nuclear relations between the United States and China should emphasize two complementary approaches: crisis stability and arms race stability. Crisis stability emphasizes the need to minimize pressure on either side to be the first to use nuclear weapons based on perceived advantage or vulnerability. It thus emphasizes the need for a strategic dynamic in which both sides see that launching their nuclear weapons first to avoid being disarmed or to try to disarm one’s opponent is unnecessary and unwise. Arms race stability focuses on the longer term and emphasizes controlling the dynamics of arms competition that can affect the strategic balance, and specifically calculations associated with first-strike stability. The Working Group believes these concepts can even be highly useful in relations between two countries that have asymmetric capabilities such as the United States and China. Such concepts do not demand that two nations have the same or similar numbers or types of forces. Rather, they are adaptable goals that can be fitted to the situation that exists between the United States and China. Based on this concept, stability can emerge between the United States and China if they each field forces that are capable of surviving a first strike and if they are able to credibly demonstrate to the other side that their current and future capabilities are unable to deny the other side a viable strategic deterrent. As a result, fear of preemption and the need to launch weapons early become irrelevant, either as irritants in crisis or as dangers in conflict. In this way, the benefits of deterrence can be retained while minimizing the chances of nuclear escalation. The premise of arms control and stability-oriented measures is that even potential adversaries can achieve the twin goals of both effective nuclear deterrence and mitigation of the possibility of conflict between them. This is because nuclear forces themselves can intensify, if not cause, competition and even conflict—but they need not. Nuclear deterrence is not simply a unilateral action that takes places in a vacuum; rather, it is a relationship shaped by perceptions. Indeed, the ways in which a country procures, postures, and operates its nuclear forces have a major interactive effect on how other countries procure, posture, and operate their forces. Potential adversaries can allay, and possibly even remove, these exacerbating factors through unilateral and cooperative measures that effectively demonstrate that each side’s strategic forces are not capable of conducting a disarming first strike. Such measures do not solve more fundamental political and strategic disputes, but they can help to lessen tensions and mistrust stemming from the essentially ancillary technical features of interstate relations. Both sides could derive value from cooperation on nuclear weapons grounded in the stability concept. The United States worries about the composition of China’s nuclear force, Chinese views on escalation and plans for nuclear use, and the future trajectory of China’s strategic posture. Meanwhile, China worries that the United States may be able or seek to be able to deny it a second-strike capability, and it worries about the scope and sophistication of future U.S. programs, as well as U.S. unwillingness to acknowledge a condition of mutual vulnerability between the two nations. A stability-grounded model could help address these anxieties—on the U.S. side by providing greater insight into China’s current and future force structure and deeper insight into China’s ways of thinking about nuclear strategy, and on the Chinese side by providing similar insight into U.S. developments and a greater degree of assurance about U.S. acknowledgment of the survivability of China’s force. Concurrently, such an approach would have the added benefit of building confidence on both sides. Finally, such a model could provide a satisfactory method through which China could see something approximating its current force size, posture, and doctrine as satisfactory and compatible with stability.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.