No spillover – China does not have broadly expansionist motives
Shifrinson, PhD, Assistant Professor of International Relations, Fredrick S. Pardee School of Global Studies, BU, ‘20
(Joshua, “The rise of China, balance of power theory and US national security: Reasons for optimism?” Journal of Strategic Studies, Vol. 43)
It is too early, however, to declare Chinese predation a fact, just as there are reasons to question whether Chinese predation is likely in the future. On one level, and consistent with research by scholars such as Avery Goldstein, Alastair Iain Johnston and others, there are less-competitive elements embedded in current Chinese strategy.61 Chinese land reclamation and military deployments in the East and South China Seas, for instance, have mostly involved territories previously claimed by the Chinese government – China has not expanded its maritime claims so much as taken a unilateral approach towards resolving existing disputes.62 Similarly, China’s ADIZ move came after Japan expanded its own ADIZ and began consolidating control over the disputed Senkaku Islands.63
It is also important to recognise that there are steps China could plausibly have undertaken in recent years yet chose not to. Despite concerns over a Chinese military build-up, for instance, China did not increase the share of state wealth allocated to military spending; military expenditures have remained at 1.9 per cent of Chinese gross domestic product (GDP) since 2009.64 Likewise, China has sustained a minimalist nuclear deterrent even though this force is vulnerable to disruption.65 Above all, China has not tried to form an anti-US alliance in East Asia – in fact, there is some evidence that China has sought to keep the United States engaged in East Asia rather than exclude it.66 For example, not only did Chinese President Xi Jinping tell US President Barack Obama in 2014 that the ‘Pacific Ocean has ample space to accommodate our two great nations,’ but China’s Xinhua news agency greeted Donald Trump’s election – after a campaign marked by calls for a reduced US role in the world – with a warning against US isolationism.67 These moves are not consistent with a predatory campaign: China is pursuing a mixed strategy that blends both cooperative and competitive elements.