Deterrence and conflict aversion both outweigh miscalc.
Horowitz & Saunders 19 Michael C. Horowitz, Political Science Professor at the University of Pennsylvania, & Elizabeth N. Saunders, Security Studies Professor at Georgetown University. [War with Iran is probably less likely than you think, the Washington Post, 6-17-19, https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2019/06/17/war-with-iran-is-probably-less-likely-than-you-think/]
Misperception rarely causes war. The spiral model may not be the right way to think about how conflicts escalate. Missed signals and miscalculation can indeed generate tension. But leaders have many ways to avoid conflicts that they do not want to fight. The historical record suggests that misperception and accidental escalation rarely lead to war — as Dan Reiter noted here at TMC during the height of North Korea tensions in 2018. Domestic political pressures don’t seem to be pushing toward war. The United States and Iran also face domestic pressures that may make both sides hesitate before escalating. Iran’s economy has suffered under the Trump administration’s renewed sanctions, and parliamentary elections are coming up. Although the country’s president, Hassan Rouhani, has used tough rhetoric recently, a costly war might not benefit Iran’s leaders, since it could inflict further economic and human costs, or even lead to regime change or collapse. Likewise, after nearly two decades of war in the Middle East and Afghanistan, Americans are unlikely to welcome another major conflict. Neither Trump’s own party nor the opposition Democrats has rallied the U.S. public to pressure Trump to escalate. As TMC’s Michael Tesler noted in December, although Trump’s base supporters tend to have hawkish views, they supported his decision to withdraw troops from Syria. If Trump does not want war with Iran, his base would likely follow. The president doesn’t seem eager for war. There has been much talk about a replay of the Iraq War, with the United States using possibly flawed intelligence to justify war. But although Trump has used limited military force in Syria, he seems generally opposed to costly wars in the Middle East, and unlikely to embrace a new one. Both Pompeo and national security adviser John Bolton are much more hawkish on Iran, but Trump has distanced himself from his advisers’ hawkish rhetoric, particularly the most costly option: regime change. [Designating an Iranian military unit a terrorist organization will make relations with Iran more difficult. Here's how.] Here’s what to watch for. So which will win out: the risks of escalation or the pressures for restraint? Amid all the tension, Iran wants its regime to survive, and Trump probably does not want to absorb a costly war. In the coming days and weeks, it will be telling to see if there is further daylight between Trump and his advisers. Here’s one more risk: if Trump’s hawkish advisers present an option that seems like it could be kept limited, but actually carries a strong likelihood of escalation. Trump has embraced limited displays of force, such as airstrikes in Syria in 2017 and 2018, and he issued a threatening tweet on Iran in May. But he has also pivoted away quickly from harsh rhetoric to diplomacy before — as he did toward North Korea — and has already achieved his campaign goal of pulling out of the nuclear deal he disdained. [Would Iran welcome a new nuclear deal? Think again.] The bottom line: Despite rising tension, powerful factors reduce the likelihood of war between the U.S. and Iran. That’s unlikely to change anytime soon.