Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

No sub bumping impact.

CACEE ’3. [Center for Arms Control, Energy and Environmental Studies at MIPT; 8-21-2003, “Preventing Submarine Collisions: Answers to the questions of U.S. nationwide policy debaters,”. https://www.armscontrol.ru/subs/collisions/debates.htm]

Part 1. Q: A team from Lexington High School in Massachusetts proposes that: "The U.S. should establish a blueprint amending current Navy protocols to preclude the tracking of Russian submarines in Russian territorial waters and necessary patrol routes." They cite your article, Collision of Two U.S. Nuclear Powered Submarines on March 1998, Our Comment as evidence supporting the passage of their policy proposal. They claim that tracking risks reactor accidents below the water and crisis escalation when a Russian sub commander launches a SLBM in response to U.S. sub bumping. What are the chances of a nuclear accident as a result from a crash? The danger of a collision is conventional explosion which results in break up of submarine nuclear reactors, and possibly nuclear warheads of the missiles, so that highly radioactive nuclear materials (nuclear weapons and nuclear fuel in submarine reactors) will be released and spread over the wide area - pretty much like what happened in Chernobyl. If there will be a strong wind toward the coast, the radioactive waste can spread deep inside the territory as well. Submarine collisions are dangerous, because they may also lead to loss of personnel and submarines. For example, in March 1993 a U.S. submarine collided with a Delta IV Class Russian submarine at the Barents Sea causing very heavy damage to the front area of the Russian submarine's hull, and also considerable damage to the front of the U.S. submarine as well (the SSN Grayling). Since the Russian missile carrying submarine was moving forward in the water when the collision occurred, had the collision happened ten to twenty seconds later, it could have resulted in the crushing of one or more of the submarine's missile compartments. Such a collision could have caused a deflagration event that could have resulted in the loss of the Russian submarine, and possibly the U.S. submarine as well. Q: Also would a nuclear accident, perhaps 3-4 nuclear accidents lead to the extinction of all life in the oceans? It seems a little crazy that this could happen but the way that most teams are winning is by claiming a crash could end all aquatic life. This statement is a little bit exaggerated. Atomic bombs destroyed both Hiroshima and Nagasaki, killed more than 200,000 people, but there was also many people who survived. Chernobyl accident inflicted a severe damage, however the whole life did not end. The danger of an accident involving nuclear materials is that it effects a very large territory and rehabilitation of the damaged territory will take hundreds years. Nuclear submarine accidents may result in release of highly radioactive and toxic materials, which are dangerous to both humans and marine life. Some species may not be preserved. There is an extensive literature on biological effects of radioactivity. You may find appropriate information in "The Effects of Nuclear Weapons" by Glasstone or in "Environmental Impact Statements on Disposal of Nuclear Submarines", produced by the U.S. Navy. Q: Has there ever been a sub accident that resulted in radioactive material spilling into the ocean? Fortunately, submarine reactors were shut down in all known accidents. There was some release of radioactivity and presumably highly radioactive wastes (like water in the coolant system). The sank submarines contained nuclear weapons on board that might have been damaged. For example, there were reports about damage of casings of plutonium tipped torpedoes aboard Soviet Mike class SSN which sank in 1989 in Norwegian Sea. Plutonium leakage is now an issue of great concern of environmentalists. Q: The Chicago Tribune from June 23, 1997 reports that a 1986 collision off of Bermuda either directly or indirectly caused the inadvertent launch of a Soviet nuclear missile... In fact there was explosion, not an inadvertent launch of a SS-N-6 missile. The fact of collision has not been proven, however there is an evidence, which supports such a hypothesis. Q:..., but the book "Hostile Waters" says that they just blew the missile hatch... The book is more reliable, because one of its authors was aboard the Yankee SSBN which sank. Q:...Is there a risk that submarine collisions might actually trigger an inadvertent missile launch, or create the situation for an unanticipated escalation to genuine attack? I do not think so. There is a certain set of conditions which are necessary to launch SLBMs. In particular, a missile submarine has to receive a launch order and permitting codes, which unlock targeting information, from a ground command center. Unlike U.S. SSBNs, Russian missile submarines can not launch missiles without such an order. Q: What is required in order for an Russian nuclear sub commander to launch his missiles? On american subs it requires the captains and the executive officers keys to unlock the firing button. What is it on Russian subs? It is impossible to give a correct answer to this question, because this is a classified information. I have seen speculations on the matter in open literature, which look quite plausible. For example, you may find some information in books written by Bruce Blair: "Global Zero Alert for Nuclear Forces" and "Logic of Accidental Nuclear War". What is important to understand, the Russian command-and-control system designed in such a way, that neither a group of "crazy submariners", nor of terrorists (not speaking about a single "berserk") can technically deliver a nuclear-tipped ballistic missile at a chosen target and explode the nuclear warhead. Even if they manage to launch an SLBM, it will be self-destructed, because of the lack of the flight mission or the latter is not confirmed from the central command center. Q: It seems that crashes have decreased since the end of the Cold War. If you speak about collisions between U.S. and Russian subs, in fact, the most recent events happened in 1992 and 1993, after the end of the Cold War. Open sources list approximately a dozen of sub-to-sub collisions in total since mid 60-s. On one hand, deployment rate of Russian submarines drastically decreased, which diminishes probability of a collision. However, Russian subs became less noisy, and this fact has an adverse effect on the chances to collide with U.S. subs attempting to trail.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.