Laundry list of structural factors that make detection impossible
Gates 16. Jonathan Gates is a defence consultant with a career spanning 35 years. In the Royal Corps of Naval Constructors, he managed multidisciplinary projects and spent a period as Engineering Director of the Al-Yamamah contract. Since 1998 he has been visiting professor at University College London’s department of Naval Architecture and Marine Engineering; “Is the SSBN Deterrent Vulnerable to Autonomous Drones?”; December 21, 2016; The RUSI Journal Volume 161, 2016 - Issue 6; https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/03071847.2016.1265834 //BY
Conclusion There are many types of autonomous vehicles currently available or in development for a potential ASW role. UAVs, UUVs and USVs are all being developed, and the tasks that they are being designed to perform are varied. However, what emerges is that the environmental conditions experienced by the different types of drone are different and this limits the types of operations that they can carry out. Unlike many of the tasks undertaken by drones in general, searching for submarines is extremely difficult as the latter are designed to disappear. For this reason, autonomous vehicles are unlikely to represent a revolutionary change, although their emerging capability will have implications for submarine and ASW operations. There is a potential evolutionary path that incorporates autonomous vehicle technology into naval operations that will improve effectiveness or lower costs. The use of autonomous vehicles (especially large, fast USVs, large ship-deployed UUVs and UAVs) could deny areas of operation to submarines, but such overt surveillance would be open to avoidance, and could be challenged by other naval vessels and countermeasures as part of a layered defence. The below-water sensors available to UAVs (laser, magnetic anomaly) and UUVs (high-frequency sonar) have very short detection ranges. Even if a submarine-like target were detected, the autonomous vehicle would need to track and classify the target as an enemy submarine and to report back to headquarters. This would require a further degree of sophistication with cost implications to be developed. The assumption that large numbers of ‘lostcost’ autonomous vehicles will make the oceans transparent is misleading because it would take an immense number of vehicles to cover even a fraction of an SSBN’s operational areas.