Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

They are strategically useless

Shah 22 [Akash Shah, Akash Shah works as a Research Officer at Strategic Vision Institute, Islamabad. His work focuses on developments and militarization in outer space. 6-19-2022, "Could the Orca Autonomous Submarine Forever Change Nuclear War?," National Interest, https://nationalinterest.org/blog/buzz/could-orca-autonomous-submarine-forever-change-nuclear-war-203085 mimou]

One of the crucial elements of a secure second-strike capability is an early warning of incoming nuclear missiles and launch platforms being communicated to strike back. However, communication with a submerged vessel is one of the most challenging aspects of underwater warfare. The stealth feature of a submarine is only viable if it is underwater as the probability of detection and interception increases when it is closer to the surface. This conundrum of communication while maintaining stealthiness is somewhat addressed by using the extremely low frequency of 3 Hz to 30 Hz.

However, in the case of autonomous unmanned submarines carrying nukes, one can never be sure if the transmitted message is conceived in time and in the manner it was intended. When compared with the potential for autonomous underwater platforms to enhance a country’s deterrence capabilities, the risk and cost, if things go wrong, are simply too high.  

Despite having little to no utility in a nuclear standoff, Orca-class submarines are still likely to have a considerable impact on the future of naval warfare. The potency of nuclear weapons is such that the core principles pertinent to their deployment and operation are more or less the same since their advent, regardless of the technology that has exponentially improved since Trinity, the first detonation of a nuclear bomb.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.