Satelite imagery is key to monitor adversaries—China and NoKo prove
NTI 21- NTI’s team brings unparalleled vision and expertise to tackling current and future threats. (“Submarine Detection and Monitoring: Open-Source Tools and Technologies,” September 24, 2021, https://www.nti.org/analysis/articles/submarine-detection-and-monitoring-open-source-tools-and-technologies/)//mcu
Readily accessible high-resolution commercial satellite imagery is one of the most important tools for open-source analysis of submarine activity. Imagery enables researchers to monitor naval shipyards and bases for activity visually, such as those in China and North Korea. For example, over the years, researchers have used satellite imagery to glean important information about China’s efforts to expand and modernize its fleet of nuclear submarines. In 2007, just as several of China’s new Jin-class (Type 094) SSBs were commissioned, Federation of American Scientists analyst Hans Kristensen began using Google Earth imagery to count the number of operational Jin-class submarines at various bases and shipyards around the country, and later to study the expansion of China’s submarine infrastructure (a network of shipyards, naval bases, underground facilities for missile storage, and submarine demagnetization facilities).4 Imagery of construction at Longpo Naval Base—the home of China’s southern SSBN fleet—revealed interesting clues about China’s SSBN program. For example, Kristensen observed the installation of China’s first submarine demagnetization facility, which strips submarine hulls of residual magnetic fields, pointing to Chinese efforts to deploy less detectable submarines.5 Catherine Dill of the Center for Nonproliferation Studies (CNS) published an article revisiting efforts to count China’s operational Jin-class submarines, but unlike Kristensen, she did so using high frequency satellite imagery from Planet Labs.6 High frequency imagery has revolutionized open-source analysis because it is characterized by a high revisit rate. Often, Planet Labs prioritizes frequent imaging of the same sites (up to twice daily) to enable rapid change detection, as well as comparison of images across multiple sites over the same time periods. Dill captured images of two critical Chinese submarine facilities—the Bohai shipyard and the Longpo Naval Base—on the same day. This enabled her to count Chinese SSBNs more accurately; when using images from different dates, there is a risk of double counting or other errors. North Korea maintains one of the largest submarine fleets in the world, estimated at between 64 and 86 submarines. The fleet is comprised primarily of conventionally-armed submarines; however, satellite imagery analysis in recent years has uncovered North Korean efforts to build a class of diesel-electric SSBs and submarine launched ballistic missiles (SLBMs).7 In 2014, open-source analysts spotted North Korea’s first Gorae-class (aka Sinpo-class) ballistic missile submarine at the Sinpo South Naval Shipyard.8 At the same time, analysts watched the development and testing of a solid-fueled SLBM that could potentially arm Gorae-class submarines.9