Imbuing elected branches with authority grants decision-making authority to present populations – that trades off with future generations – only the cp solves
Tremmel 13 [Joerg Chet Tremmel is a Professor for "intergenerationally just policies" at the University of Tuebingen. He is Editor-in-chief of the Intergenerational Justice Review and a visiting lecturer at the Johann-Wolfgang-Goethe-University Frankfurt, the University of Stuttgart and the Heinrich-Heine-University in Dusseldorf, Germany. An extended separation of powers model as the theoretical basis for the representation of future generations. July 26, 2013. https://www.futurejustice.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/11/Paper_Future-Branch_Tremmel.pdf]
And rightly so. The absence of representation of future generations means that conflicts of interest are decided by the majority of eligible voters, not the majority of those affected by the decision. Future people that are relevantly affected by a decision don’t have any influence over it. This ‘representation gap’ is fundamentally different from deficiencies in the participatory rights of other social minorities or interest groups for which representation is also lacking (e.g. women, the elderly, or foreigners). These groups are present here and now; they can take part in political discourse, write opinion-editorials, appear on talk-shows and in many cases participate in elections. None of these options are available to future generations. “The future is another country”, states Posner,8 paraphrasing that the welfare of future generations is as low on the agenda of political incumbents as the welfare of a foreign country.
If future citizens could assert their interests in the political decision-making process, majority outcomes in important political decisions of the present would be different. Energy policy is a good example: Energy production of present generations, which relies heavily on fossil fuels, provides a high standard of living today, but at the expense of creating serious disadvantages for the medium-term future of fifty to a hundred years. Post-1990 - the year in which the IPCC’s First Assessment Report assessed a connection between anthropogenic carbon dioxide emissions and climate change with a 90 per cent probability- presently living generations can no longer legitimately claim ignorance of the consequences of their actions. Scientific analyses indicate that current energy policy intensifies the natural greenhouse effect and causes the global average temperature to rise.9 Let’s assume that the future individuals born in the next 200 years could partake in the next general election, in the present. The consequence would be that all parties would rewrite their official party positions on today’s energy policy and implement a much more rapid decline in carbon dioxide emissions. The same effect could be achieved if a future branch were implemented in the set-up of democracies as a fourth power in the separation of powers model.
Especially with regard to environmental matters, the effects of current actions extend far into the future and have the potential to seriously negatively influence the quality of life of numerous future generations, as figure 1 shows.10
In light of these facts, a prolongation of the legislative session seems appropriate. However, election periods cannot even come close to corresponding to the time span in which the effects of political decisions are felt without restricting voters’ influence in such a way that would endanger the very essence of democracy.
Problems posed by the short-sightedness of democracies are not limited to ecological issues. Long before the emergence of modern environmental movements, excessive national debts were considered a prime example of carelessness with regard to the future. As early as 1816 Thomas Jefferson discussed potential solutions to this problem.11 Insufficient investments in education or failing to adjust pay-as-you-go social security systems are further examples of lacking long-term orientation in political systems.
Modern democracies are either direct democracies (prime example: Switzerland) or organised according to the principle of representation. Both democratic forms are legitimate; the principle of representation is therefore neither an essential element of democracy nor does it contradict it. In this respect, democratic principles do not oppose an extension of the principle of representation to cover future people. The representation of future people is thus compatible with democratic principles. As Gohler notes, “In the broadest sense of the term, representation means to make something invisible visible and something absent present’’.12 Thaa adds that representation should be understood as “the visualisation of an absentee".13 Although this phrase may have been coined in a different context, it cannot be better expressed.
Lack of liability for inadequate performance in office
An additional issue amplifies this orientation to the present: In democracies, politicians’ governmental responsibility is for a limited amount of time. Indeed, this is one of the advantages of this system of government. However, it also means that an elected official does not have to assume that his own shortsighted decisions will catch up with [them] him twenty or thirty years later. As soon as a new government comes into power, she is no longer liable.