Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The CP applies the future generations standard – that’s better than trying to decide now whether the plan is beneficial across deep time

Kuroda 21 [Masashi Kuroda, Michinori Uwasu, Xuan-Thanh Bui, Phuoc-Dan Nguyen, and Keishiro Hara, * Faculty of Social and Environmental Studies, Tokoha University, “Shifting the perception of water environment problems by introducing “imaginary future generations”—Evidence from participatory workshop in Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam,” 2021, Futures, Vol. 126, https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0016328720301622, EA]

Sustainable water management is essential for sustaining a fruitful and stable living environment. While developed countries, including Japan, have previously experienced serious water contamination due to rapid economic growth, those countries faced the problem by implementing a suitable legal framework and appropriate technology, and today they maintain good water environments (Bai & Imura, 2000; Kuroda, Hara, Takekawa, Uwasu, & Ike, 2018; Okada & Peterson, 2000). Nonetheless, these countries have been recently facing different challenges, such as renewal and maintenance of old water supply and sewage systems, and a myopic perspective cannot aid in properly maintaining and managing this infrastructure. Meanwhile, various Asian cities, including Vietnamese cities, are now undergoing rapid economic and population growth and are facing water quality and quantity problems caused by urbanization and industrialization. Moreover, the long-term environmental impact of various economic activities cannot be ignored. Groundwater is used widely for industrial and agricultural activities, as well as for domestic purposes, because it is relatively cheap compared with surface water treatment, and the water quality is stable. In these regions, due to the expanding use of groundwater triggered by socio-economic growth, some social problems are surfacing, including falling groundwater levels caused by excessive water consumption and the resulting land subsidence and saltwater intrusion (Hara, 2006; Ngo, Lee, Lee, & Woo, 2014). Once such land subsidence occurs, it is irreversible, posing threats and conveying disadvantages to subsequent future generations. Furthermore, the pollution of groundwater is increasing due to industrialization and urbanization. Groundwater is retained for extremely long periods, ranging from several years to several decades, so once such water becomes polluted, it has a lasting impact on future generations as well. These phenomena stand as examples of how unrestrained consumption and use of water resources to fulfill the short-term needs of present generations are making it difficult to realize sustainable management and stable use of groundwater resources. To make full use of limited water resources in a sustainable manner, it is indispensable to address water resources management by accounting for the benefits to future generations and integrating the perspective of intergenerational equity.

Meanwhile, Saijo (2018) argues that it is difficult to make decisions in a long-term context under the given natural human characteristics such as impulse (Sapolsky, 2012) and optimism (Sharot, 2011), as well as the fundamental systems in modern society, such as markets, which function to satisfy the needs of the present. These factors lead to shortsighted decision making that conflicts with the interests of future generations (Saijo, 2019). Therefore, it is important to create a framework and methodology that can be used to practice long-term decision making and implement measures that reflect the perspectives of future generations and their needs, as well as an appropriate intergenerational balance.

Against this backdrop, “future design” attempts to integrate the perspectives of future generations with contemporary decision-making process by designing social systems that allows future generations to inherit a sustainable society (Saijo, 2018, 2020). One promising approach that has been proven to be effective is the creation of an “imaginary future generation” (IFG) in our society as a stakeholder tasked with representing future generations and negotiating with decision making groups in the current generation (Hara & Saijo, 2017; Hara, Kuroda, Yoshioka, Kurimoto, & Saijo, 2019, Hara, Kitakaji et al., 2019; Kamijo, Komiya, Mifune, & Saijo, 2017; Saijo, 2018, 2019). Past studies, including both lab-scale experiments and societal experiments, have demonstrated that placing ourselves in the shoes of future generations (i.e., via the IFG concept) results in avoiding shortsighted decision making and creating new perspectives related to the benefit of future generations. In the first lab-scale experiment, groups that included IFGs increased the capacity and possibility for making decisions that reserved monetary resources for future generations even if that meant reducing remuneration to the groups (Kamijo et al., 2017). Further, future design deliberation practices with IFGs facilitated intergenerational consensus building and the production of proposals that could benefit both current and future generations (Hara & Saijo, 2017; Hara, Kuroda et al., 2019). Moreover, the visions and judgement of IFG groups appeared to be quite different from those of groups representing the current generation. Indeed, IFG groups proposed innovative ideas and long-term perspectives, which have been neglected by the current generation (Hara, Kuroda et al., 2019).

The backcasting approach is also often employed to envision a sustainable future society (Kishita, Hara, Uwasu, & Umeda, 2016). Backcasting is a normative scenario approach that generates future visions assessed in terms of desirability and attainability and explores pathways that may bring about or avoid this future in an incremental fashion (van der Voorn, Pahl-Wostl, & Quist, 2012; van der Voorn, Quist, Pahl-Wostl, & Haasnoot, 2017). Although the participation of and the deliberation among stakeholders are the important factors to develop a robust scenario, an appropriate methodology of scenario design that can build a consensus of a desirable future image by integrating all the opinions from the different standpoints of stakeholders has not well established. In addition, the current method of backcasting hardly includes the needs and preferences of future generations, who are the important stakeholders in the process of designing a sustainable society, in an explicit manner. Uwasu, Kishita, Hara, and Nomaguchi (2020) discussed that the creation of IFG in the deliberation of scenario design could improve such aspect of backcasting. The study reported that current generations agreed with the proposals by IFGs that impose proactive burdens for current generations to facilitate the realization of desirable future even after the workshop of scenario design, which suggests that the future design settings may solve the confrontation between current and future generations by liberating the current generation from their self-righteous behavior (Hara, Kuroda et al., 2019; Hara, Kitakaji et al., 2019).

This future design approach has been applied to themes such as energy issues and urban planning, but none of the studies conducted to date have addressed the issue of the water environment in terms of identifying problems and prioritizing measures to address them. Water-related problems change over time and across countries, and we hypothesize that using the perspective of a future generation could provide new insights into what kinds of water environment problems should be prioritized from a long-term perspective.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.