DURABILITY – only the cp solves solvency in the future – inevitable political pressures down the road causes circumvention and undermine signal of durability
Boston 14 [Jonathan Boston, Professor of Public Policy, School of Government, Victoria University of Wellington, Fulbright Fellow, American University. Governing for the Future: How to bring the long-term into short-term political focus. November 5, 2014. https://www.american.edu/spa/cep/upload/jonathan-boston-lecture-american-university.pdf]
To compound matters, the long-term governance problem has two of the three characteristics associated with ‘super-wicked’ problems, at least as defined by Richard Lazarus (2009). For one thing, those endeavouring to solve the problem are also amongst the very people who are causing it. Hence, they are likely to face contradictory pressures. For another, there is no inter-temporal authority or governance structure enduring across multiple generations that is able to enforce lasting solutions, ensure that costly long-term policy investments are properly implemented or hold recalcitrant governments to account. Accordingly, whatever policy farsightedness the current generation of policy-makers may be able to muster at any given juncture they face two related, ongoing challenges. First, there the long-term assurance or compliance problem: how can policy makers ensure that their successors also exercise farsightedness? Second, there is the problem of‘dynamic inconsistency’ or ‘time inconsistency’ - that is, a person’s preferences in Time 1 may diverge from their preferences in Time 2, and their future actions may undermine their earlier decisions. In terms of policy consistency, how can political leaders bind their future selves to remain committed to a prudent long-term strategy, especially if there are powerful, electorally-driven temptations to defect? If such problems cannot be overcome, there is an obvious risk that prudent, long-term policy investments will not deliver their hoped-for gains. This risk, in turn, poses a further challenge: what is the logic of making costly policy investments today if the long-term payoffs are highly uncertain? After all, there is little point making hard choices in the short-term if there is little prospect of future benefits. The immediate question posed by such a dilemma is whether policy-makers can bind themselves and their successors in order to increase the chances of desirable long-term goals being achieved. Is some kind of commitment device available and, if so, what particular sort of device might be most appropriate and effective? I will return to this matter shortly.