Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

States are looking to incorporate future generations in water law now but only the counterplan’s codification legitimizes it and spills over

Spijkers 21 [Otto Spijkers, Professor of International Law at Wuhan University’s China Institute of Boundary and Ocean Studies (CIBOS) as well as its Research Institute of Environmental Law (RIEL) and Founding Staff Member of its International Water Law Academy (IWLA). He is also a member of the Committee on the Role of International Law in Sustainable Natural Resource Management for Development of the International Law Association. “Equity across Generations in Implementing International Law on Water.” Future Trends. (2021). In M. Cordonier Segger, M. Szabó, & A. Harrington (Eds.), Intergenerational Justice in Sustainable Development Treaty Implementation: Advancing Future Generations Rights through National Institutions (Treaty Implementation for Sustainable Development, pp. 703-791). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.]

This chapter first examined the relationship between the principle of intergenerational equity and the two most fundamental principles of international water law – the no harm rule and the principle of equitable utilization – as reflected in the UN Watercourses Convention. It then looked at how this relationship between intergenerational equity and water law’s foundational principles played out in specific agreements regulating a particular transboundary watercourse. Many of these agreements use the Watercourses Convention’s proclamation of the principles as starting point, but then add more intergenerational elements to them. It appears that States are more and more confident in doing so, and thus the principles slowly evolve into more sustainable, intergenerational versions of themselves.

We also see this evolution in domestic law and policies. All examples referred to above have attempted to find a way to share the burdens and benefits of freshwater resource management and utilization among the present and future generations. The exact formulation of this balance differs. Sometimes the present generation has an obligation to ensure that future generations have at least as many resources and opportunities as the present generation currently has. Sometimes the present generation is asked only to keep the interests of future generations in mind when utilizing the freshwater resources. Very few legal frameworks give a role to representatives of future generations as participants. It is more common for the present generation to simply accept an obligation for itself to take into account the interests of future generations, without giving the latter any means to ensure compliance with this commitment. If we take all these examples together, we find an interesting laboratory of intellectual experiments, most of them of very recent date, which may provide a source of inspiration. The question of how to ensure compliance with these water laws remains beyond the scope of this chapter, but the next step is to faithfully carry out those plans and to respect the commitments that have been made to present and future generations.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.