Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Using an amendment solves debates over constitutionality and legitimacy challenges.

Tushnet 5 [Mark Tushnet, Felix Frankfurter Visiting Professor of Law, Harvard Law School; Carmack Waterhouse Professor of Constitutional Law, Georgetown University Law Center. Controlling Executive Power in the War on Terrorism. Harvard Law Review, 2005. Hein Online]

Perhaps we could be persuaded that this new institution’s design did indeed conform to the constraints on institutional innovation imposed by the existing Constitution. I am sure, though, that the discussion of the proposal’s soundness as a matter of policy would be polluted by discussions of whether the proposal, if enacted, would be constitutional.38 Those in favor of such an institution on policy grounds might find themselves arguing — perhaps somewhat disingenuously — that the innovation is indeed compatible with the Constitution. We could avoid such distractions if the proposal were cast as a constitutional amendment.39

The amendment process is a difficult one, of course, and the problems we face may seem so pressing that they need to be addressed immediately, such as through litigation under the existing Constitution. As I have observed elsewhere, however, at the time of this writing Jos£ Padilla remains incarcerated, uncharged and with only a single trial judge having evaluated the grounds for his detention, nearly three years after he was taken into custody.40 It is not obvious to me that the problems posed by Padilla’s detention would have been solved less promptly had we begun to consider constitutional amendments to deal with his circumstances — and, more generally, with the design of institutions to ensure the responsible exercise of power in the war on terrorism — as soon as he was detained. Waiting for the existing Constitution to solve the problems thrust on the nation, that is, may take more time than amending the Constitution.41

BEGIN FOOTNOTE 41

41 Of course, the political conditions that affect assessment of the President’s actions would also affect the amendment process. In that process, though, the politics would affect consideration of a proposal rather than of an action already taken, and it seems to me that the politics surrounding proposals differ from those surrounding completed actions. It seems appropriate to note as well that my advocacy of a constitutional amendment process is designed as much to get our thinking unstuck as to propose a practical political program.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.