[3] Independent oversight is legitimate and constitutional
Smith 15 [Graham Smith, Foundation for Democracy and Sustainable Development. The Democratic Case for an Office for Future Generations. April 2015. www.fdsd.org/site/wp-content/uploads/2015/04/Office-for-Future-Generations-FDSD-format.81.pdf] Note: OFG = Offices for Future Generations
It is a common refrain that democracies tend to privilege the short-term. Institutional solutions are needed to ameliorate such myopic tendencies. Offices for Future Generations (OFGs) - (quasi) independent bodies charged with promoting long-term thinking and the interests of future generations in the political process - are currently the focus of political interest at different levels of governance.
The Hungarian Ombudsman for Future Generations is the most well known example, the Israeli’s recently decommissioned their equivalent body and a Commissioner for Future Generations has nearly completed its legislative progress at the time of writing in Wales. Such an Office need not be restricted to the level of the nation state: FDSD has itself actively participated in debates about the creation of a UN High Commissioner for Future Generations (FDSD/World Future Council, 2012).
There is something pleasingly counter-intuitive in this particular institutional design. For many, the idea of such independent oversight bodies has the ring of an anti-democratic reform: further advancing the regulatory state and taking power away from traditional democratic institutions such as parliament.
But, without assuming that the establishment of such an Office is the single institutional solution for realizing long-term thinking, there are good democratic reasons for giving this institutional design serious consideration.
One such reason is given by the French political philosopher Pierre Rosanvallon who argues that: ‘democracy can flourish only if it acknowledges the risks of dysfunctionality and equips itself with institutions capable of subjecting its own inner workings to constructive evaluation' (Rosanvallon 2008: 74-5, italics in original). An OFG is one such institutional innovation that acknowledges and responds to the dysfunctionalities generated by short-termism in democratic systems.
An OFG may also have an important role to play in promoting opportunities for participatory engagement; its very legitimacy and institutional sustainability may in fact rest on such a strategy.