Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Amendments guarantee enforcement – no chance of circumvention

Denning and Vile 2 (Brannon P., Assistant Professor of Law – Southern Illinois University School of Law, and John R., Political Science Department Chair – Middle Tennessee State University, “The Relevance of Constitutional Amendments: A Response to David Strauss,” Tulane Law Review, November, 77 Tul. L. Rev. 247, Lexis)

D. Legitimization The Article V process is, as the Framers intended, rigorous. The supermajority provisions for both proposal and ratification almost always guarantee that additions will not be made to the Constitution without both deep and broad support. Though some have criticized the necessity of such supermajorities, n127 holding additions to the Constitution in abeyance until it is clear that support is broad generally prevents populous regions from dominating less populous ones. This, in turn, allows the amendment to become part of the Constitution with a near-conclusive presumption of legitimacy. This legitimacy, then, helps free the other branches (courts, for example) to enforce it vigorously; indeed, such enforcement would likely be expected after an amendment makes it through Article V's arduous process. And if, after popular expectations were raised through the debates over proposal and ratification, the amendment is not enforced, institutions responsible for the foot-dragging may again face costs for evasion. This legitimization element is so crucial that the examples Strauss cites of amendments that, he argues, did not do anything immediately (the Reconstruction Amendments) or are not likely to have a significant effect despite their eventual ratification (the Twenty-Seventh Amendment), n128 could be cited as proof of what [*279] happens when attempts are made to short-circuit (or play games with) Article V's procedural requirements. n129 E. The Publicity Function of Written Amendments Proposals for constitutional amendment inevitably attract publicity. The debates in Congress publicize the change and allow a forum for proponents and opponents of the change to make their case both to members of Congress and to those who will eventually be called upon to ratify the amendment, if passed. Even amendments that Strauss would characterize as "do-nothing" amendments (the Twenty-Seventh Amendment, for example) received the attention of Congress and the press n130 that only the most dramatic informal constitutional changes do. The educative function of the debate aside, if proposed and ratified, a formal amendment undeniably changes the Constitution in one significant respect: it adds language to the Constitution. Thus, to every person who bothers to look at a copy of the Constitution, the change will be noticed. This textual referent, being available and apparent, enables more people to understand the fact that there has been constitutional change and to take note of it than if the change comes informally, as the culmination of doctrinal evolution in the Supreme Court or by accretions that harden into custom in the other branches. The publicity accompanying the change may, in fact, increase public expectations that the change will be honored by the other branches, raising the costs of evasion or under-enforcement. n131

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.