Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Constitutional convention solves, remains limited, and spurs congressional follow-on.

Thomas H. Neale, 3-29-2016 - Specialist in American National Government at the Congressional Research Service; “The Article V Convention to Propose Constitutional Amendments: Contemporary Issues for Congress,” Congressional Research Service, https://fas.org/sgp/crs/misc/R42589.pdf

The Limited Convention The concept of a limited convention has commanded considerable support in the debate over the Article V alternative. A range of constitutional scholars maintains that, contrary to Charles Black’s assertion, quoted earlier, a convention may be limited to a specific issue or issues contained in state applications; in fact, some observers maintain that it must be so limited. A fundamental assumption from their viewpoint is that the framers did not contemplate a general or large-scale revision of the Constitution when they drafted Article V. The late Senator Sam Ervin, who supported the Article V alternative and championed advance congressional planning for a convention, expounded this point of view: ... there is strong evidence that what the members of the [original constitutional] convention were concerned with ... was the power to make specific amendments.... [The] provision in article V for two exceptions to the amendment power42 underlines the notion that the convention anticipated a specific amendment or amendments rather than general revision.43 Another commentator, championing state authority in the convention issue, asserted that the founders’ intention in establishing the alternative amendment process was to check the ability of Congress to impede proposal of an amendment that enjoyed widespread support. He claimed that a convention limited to an issue specified by the states in their applications would be constitutional, but that a convention could be limited by the states, but not by Congress: Congress may not impose its will on the convention.... The purpose of the Convention Clause is to allow the States to circumvent a recalcitrant Congress. The Convention Clause, therefore, must allow the States [but not Congress] to limit a convention in order to accomplish this purpose.44 The primacy of the states in this viewpoint thus suggests that a convention could be open and general, or limited, depending on the applications of the legislatures. For its part, Congress has historically embraced the limited convention. When considering this question in the past, it has claimed the authority to call the convention, but also asserted a constitutional duty to respect the state application process, and to limit the subject of amendments to the subject areas cited therein. For instance, in 1984, the Senate Judiciary Committee claimed Congress’s power both to set and to enforce limits on the subject or subjects considered by an Article V Convention to those included in the state petitions. The committee’s report on the Constitutional Convention Implementation Act of 1984 (S. 119, 98th Congress), stated: Under this legislation, it is the States themselves, operating through the Congress, which are ultimately responsible for imposing subject-matter limitations upon the Article V Convention.... the States are authorized to apply for a convention “for the purpose of proposing one or more specific amendments.” Indeed, that is the only kind of convention within the scope of the present legislation, although there is no intention to preclude a call for a “general” or “unlimited” convention.45 Twenty-six years later, a 2010 study by the Goldwater Institute reached a similar conclusion. Examining the contemporary documents from the time of the 1787 Constitutional Convention, author Robert Natelson asserted that the founders anticipated the Article V Convention device would serve chiefly as an agent of the states. The states would set a convention’s agenda by specifying the questions it would address, with the convention bound to respect the limits of this mandate.46 Congress, in this viewpoint, facilitates the will of the people acting through their state legislatures: if they call for a convention to consider one or more specific policy proposals, then Congress is obliged to call for an appropriately limited convention. Conversely, if the states were to apply for a general convention, then, by this reasoning, Congress would respect their intentions.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.