Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Amendments are key – judicial action is often incoherent

Vermeule 4 (Adrian, Professor of Law – Harvard Law School, “Constitutional Amendments and the Constitutional Common Law,” Public Law and Legal Theory Working Paper No. 73, University of Chicago Law School, September, http://www.law.uchicago.edu/files/files/73-av-amendments.pdf)

I shall not question (iii) here, although there is much to be said in praise of incoherence in law, especially in constitutional law. Good coherence is better than incoherence, but bad coherence is worse than incoherence; coherence raises the stakes of constitutional decisionmaking by propagating either good or bad decisions through the legal system. Nor shall I question the dubious historical premise of the argument—that the framers designed a coherent constitutional scheme, as opposed to aggregating competing values and preferences, through horse-trading, into a patchwork document. Those issues aside, the rationale offered in (ii) exemplifies the nirvana illusion that underpins the generic case against amendments. The comparison between the framers’ globally coherent design, on the one hand, and piecemeal amendment on the other is not the right comparison to make. The principal substitute for formal amendment is not formal constitutional conventions, but judicial updating of constitutional law through flexible interpretation. The question, then, is whether piecemeal amendment produces greater incoherence than piecemeal judicial updating, carried out in particular litigated cases, by judicial institutions whose agenda is partly set by outside actors.

There is little reason to believe the latter process more conducive to coherence than the former, and much evidence to suggest that judicial decisionmaking produces a great deal of doctrinal incoherence. We should disavow any implicit picture of judgemade constitutional law as an intricately crafted web of principles whose extension and weight has been reciprocally adjusted. Precisely because judicial updating requires overrulings, reinterpretations, and other breaks in the web of prior doctrine, a system that relies on judicial updating to supply constitutional change—the system that the generic case tends to produce—generates internal pressures towards incoherent doctrine. Constitutional adjudication in America, let us recall, has produced both Plessy v. Ferguson and Brown v. Board, both Lochner v. New York and West Coast Hotel v. Parrish, both Myers v. United States and Humphrey’s Executor, both Dennis v. United States and Brandenburg v. Ohio, both Wickard v. Filburn and Lopez v. United States, both Bowers v. Hardwick and Lawrence v. Texas. Whatever else can be said about this judicial work-product, and whatever other justifications can be given for judge-made constitutional law, deep inner coherence does not seem either a plausible description of the terrain or even a plausible regulative ideal for the system.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.