Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

[1] Amending sends a powerful and clear global signal

Sarah P. Herlihy 6, J.D. from Chicago-Kent College of Law, “Amending the Natural Born Citizen Requirement: Globalization as The Impetus and The Obstacle”, Chicago-Kent Law Review, 81 Chi.-Kent L. Rev. 275, Lexis

7. The Signal this Amendment Would Send to the Rest of the World

Americans may oppose a Constitutional amendment because of the international perception that it would create. Even though the increase of globalization dictates that America should amend the natural born citizen requirement, Americans may oppose a Constitutional amendment because this type of change would signal to the rest of the world that America is willing to be one country of many and that Americans are interested in becoming part of a global world culture. Commentators refer to the symbolic nature of the law as the "expressive function of law" and recognize that Constitutional amendments may have a dual effect. For example, a Constitutional amendment to ban flag burning may not only deter people from burning American flags but also signal how important patriotism is to America. Similarly, opponents of a Constitutional amendment to amend the natural born citizen clause may believe that such an amendment would have dual effects. In addition to allowing naturalized citizens to become president, this amendment would signal to the global community that Americans want to become integrated with the rest of the world and that Americans no longer feel the need to be the leading country in the world but are content in being on equal footing with every other country. Although some Americans may believe that the expressive function of a Constitutional amendment is a positive signal to send, United States foreign [*296] policy indicates otherwise. Specifically, the United States government, led by the President who is elected by the people, takes great care in preserving its position as the world's only superpower. In light of this consistent policy, it is doubtful that Americans will support an amendment to the presidential eligibility clause because this could send the wrong signal to the rest of the world.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.