You’re biased against future impacts in risk calculus – that makes a litany of unpredictable, catastrophic threats inevitable, which approach us in irrational, non-linear ways
White and Haughton 17 [Iain White, Geography and Environmental Planning, University of Waikato. Graham Haughton, University of Manchester. Risky times: Hazard management and the tyranny of the present. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction Volume 22, June 2017, Pages 412-419. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2212420916305696]
This paper examines how the processes and practices of hazard management skew decision-making towards current concerns, shaping the treatment of the future in the present. We reveal how norms of science and policy combine to manage the complexity, uncertainty and intangibility inherent in working to long-term time horizons by defining, bounding and codifying how we understand the future. These processes, we argue, frequently but not inevitably, constrain the influence of long-term considerations, resulting in ‘hazardscapes’ where risks become embedded spatially, transferred temporally and difficult for future generations to reverse. We introduce the notion of a ‘tyranny of the present’ as a means to critique the ways in which the future is heard in risk management, that is, how the future is known, bounded, and incorporated, and the legacies that this may create. Overall, we highlight how more effective management of risks is not just a matter of better data or improved policy, rather that discourses of risk are subject to a ‘presentist’ bias, the underpinnings of which need to be better understood in order to make more effective decisions for future generations.
1. Introduction
The impact and the incidence of disasters associated with environmental hazards has been on the rise. In a 2015 study, UNISDR [52] estimated that since 2005 around 1.5 bn people have been affected globally, involving economic costs of around US$1.3 trillion. In response there has been an emphasis on improving risk management by increasing understanding of environmental hazards and their potential impacts, notably when and where they may happen, how damaging they might be, or who and what is most vulnerable. Due to the emphasis on both incidence and impact, risk management is inherently interdisciplinary, situated at the nexus of science and society. The approach has been characterized as ‘evidence-led’, where science assesses risks and enables decisions to take into account multiple scales and time periods [50], [52]. Typical measures focus on understanding the probability of future events, with policy aiming to address future risks, for instance, by delineating areas as inappropriate for development due to high flood risk [49], ‘red-zoning’ properties in areas of high seismic risk [46], or reducing the potential for damage by improving current building standards ([7]).
It is at this juncture of the voices of the present and the future that this paper is positioned. Specifically, we examine how effective current decision-making processes are at considering future hazards. This is a critical and challenging issue if society wants to adapt to future threats, such as those presented by climate change. While we can make the future more knowable and predictable through improved evidence or scientific modelling, risks can be unruly and resist temporal demarcation: hazards do not necessarily advance towards us in a rational, linear, and readily predictable fashion. In the face of global climate change, the risk environment is becoming more dynamic, with patterns of change increasing in speed, uncertainty and complexity. For instance, more frequent extreme weather events may change patterns of coastal erosion and flooding. This move to a more complex risk milieu poses challenges for disciplines that regulate future development, not least planning and legal systems, which rely on clarity and certainty in decision-making, with limited flexibility to address changing risks ([27], [30], [48], [56]). Once development is consented, unless conditions specify otherwise, this tends to be granted in perpetuity in order to provide certainty for developers. This system however, whilst reducing private or developer risks, can create new societal risks by locking-in land uses that may be difficult to transform, resulting in higher remedial costs and exposure to risks that could have been potentially avoided ([4], [44]).
We use New Zealand as a case study to explore the way that the future, and future risks in particular, are understood and considered in land use planning. Risk from this perspective is usually defined as consisting of three other variables: hazard, exposure and vulnerability, but it should be noted that these are also dependent variables. As Oliver-Smith et al. ([38]: 5) explain: ‘Most hazard is a reflection of both socially constructed as well as physical processes; exposure is a reflection of how social relations of production unfold in territory and geography; while vulnerability characterizes a range of social, economic, political and cultural conditions.’ New Zealand is one of the most exposed countries in the world to environmental hazards [20], being subject to a wide range of perils, such as tsunamis, flooding, coastal erosion, wildfires, earthquakes and volcanic eruptions. It is also one of the most hazard aware countries globally, particularly after experiencing the devastating 2010–2011 Canterbury earthquakes, which had a significant impact upon the thinking of citizens, government, and scientists alike [29], [43]. Selecting one country also enables a multi-hazard approach to be taken, which allows more general messages to be taken for other countries similarly grappling with the effective management of hazards. The data collection was qualitative and interpretive to effectively unpack the expert views and privileged knowledge that exists at the science-policy interface. It consisted of in-depth interviews with 24 key people connected with hazard planning. These were selected to provide a wide-ranging overview of perspectives from critical actors and agencies across multiple scales, sectors, locations and risks. Interviewees included central government officials, regional and district council officials who have been active in this field, researchers and scientific advisors to government on climate change and hazard management, politicians, and representatives from planning, local government, and the insurance industry.
This article has a number of key messages. Firstly, that the future brings three main challenges for decision-making: complexity, uncertainty and intangibility, and that science and policy norms in risk management struggle to deal with these. Compared to immediate policy concerns, hazards in the distant future appear more phantasmagoric—far off and insubstantial—in comparison to the ‘facts’ provided by historic data sets, or the expediency and materiality of short-term political concerns. This brings us to our second point: the broad structures of risk management foster a ‘tyranny of the present’ that needs to be recognised and mitigated in policy in order to allow future risks to have a stronger voice in current decision making.