Future crises can erupt from anywhere – breaking down presentism is key to reslience -- precisely predicting causes and consequences is impossible
West 16 [Darrell West is an American author, political scientist, and political commentator. West is the vice president and director of governance studies and director of the center for technology innovation at the Brookings Institution. Megachange: Economic Disruption, Political Upheaval, and Social Strife in the 21st Century -- Chapter 1, Overcoming Presentism. 2016. https://www.brookings.edu/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/chapter-one-_-megachange.pdf]
It is no accident that large-scale change is taking place in the contemporary period. Many of the beliefs and institutions that once anchored international and domestic affairs have grown weak. Political tidal waves have occurred in many parts of the world. We live in an era where major events occur on a seemingly regular basis.6 Megachange refers to dramatic shifts in social, economic, or political phenomena. These alter-ations can include economic disruptions, political upheaval, or social strife, among other things. Any one of these can generate ramifications that go beyond the small-scale, incremental shifts that historically typified many societal developments.
While the extent and pace of change today seems exceptionally dramatic, the current period is not the first to show evidence of large-scale change. Throughout history, empires and civilizations came and went with regularity. Nations rose in prominence and then collapsed due to economic challenges, foreign invasion, internal conflicts, or natural disasters. Dramatic scientific discoveries disrupted business practices, or new societal orders such as the Reformation and the Industrial Revolution fundamentally altered people’s lives.
In more recent times, there also have been major shifts. For example, the United States faced substantial transformations in the 1860s during and after the Civil War, again in the 1930s due to the Great Depression, and in the 1960s with the rise of the civil rights, women’s liberation, and environmental movements. In a relatively short time, large-scale disruptions altered society and politics and left a lasting imprint on those eras.
In various epochs, there have been significant fluctuations in public policies or citizen attitudes associated with social, political, or economic change. For example, following a period of social and religious turmoil, an American prohibition on the production and sale of alcohol was adopted nationally in 1920 and remained in effect until 1933. After women began organizing politically in the late 1800s, Western countries gradually adopted female suffrage, including the United States in 1920 through a constitutional amendment. Reflecting the shifting cultural mores of a later period, a dramatic 1973 U. S. Supreme Court decision legalized abortion across the country.7
It never is easy to disentangle causes and consequences of large-scale transformations. As I describe in this volume, change is chaotic and multifaceted and therefore hard to pin down precisely. One has to look over a period of time to see what is shifting and what forces are generating the most substantial alterations.
Yet through case studies, it is possible to elucidate the megachanges that have affected global affairs and American politics in recent decades. Domestically, we see megachange in shifting attitudes toward same-sex marriage, tobacco smoking, marijuana legalization, income inequality, terrorism, and border security. Globally, we have witnessed the rise and collapse of the “Arab Spring,” the reemergence of religious zealotry, the violence of nonstate actors, and challenges to the open flow of people, goods, and services long associated with globalization.
Sometimes, what happens internationally influences domestic politics, or vice versa. Extremism in one locale can provoke tensions far from the original site. In an era of global communications and speedy information transmission, seemingly small events can reverberate elsewhere and become a catalyst for dramatic change in domestic or international affairs.
The term “quantum leap,” borrowed from physicists, has come to popularly mean large-scale changes that leap-frog existing knowledge and introduce new ways of thinking. Philosophers talk about “paradigm shifts” where theoretical frameworks change dramatically. Biologists refer to models of “punctuated equilibrium” in which there is a time of great change followed by periods of equilibrium.8 Digital experts emphasize “disruptive technology” that challenges old ways of doing things and leads to the rise of companies that take advantage of, or even help create, new market realities.9
Unusual developments also periodically take place in politics. As pointed out by commentator Jeff Greenfield, “There are times in politics when the Black Swan shows up; when a highly unlikely, highly improbable event shatters years’ worth of assumptions.”10 Political earthquakes no longer seem very rare, as demonstrated by the unlikely emergence of Donald Trump in 2016.
In the area of economics, Tyler Cowen argues that “average is over.”11 Because of the great stagnation after 2008, he now believes it is going to be difficult to generate robust and sustained economic growth. The past is not prologue to the future. Rather, a number of factors will restrict prosperity unless substantial action is taken to reverse the current tide.
Extending that notion is a book by economist James K. Galbraith. He has written about the “end of normal.” Analyzing macroeconomic performance, he says that people should not project economic growth from the 1950s through 2000 into the future. Many of the conditions that gave rise to strong performance have disappeared, and it is going to be difficult to maintain past trends in the near-future.12
Economist Robert Gordon argues that we are seeing a major change in growth patterns. In his recent volume, The Rise and Fall of American Growth, he claims the dramatic growth that marked the period from 1870 to 1970 has ended and there no longer are major advances in labor productivity or societal innovation. With an aging population and high inequality, the U.S. standard of living is likely to stagnate or even fall.15
Running through each of these notions is the idea that something big is happening in the current period. Social, economic, and political patterns no longer are fixed but are generating rapid and transformative shifts. People need to be prepared for a scope of change that is grander than typically envisioned. Until we better understand these tectonic movements, it will be difficult for individuals and societies as a whole to deal with their extraordinary impact.
Big Moves Abroad
Internationally, there are numerous signs of major developments and shifting alignments. For most of the past seven decades, strong international norms seemed to guarantee the sanctity of national borders. Given the widespread aggression leading up to and during World War II and the great loss of life that resulted, modern nations generally have refrained from foreign invasions. They do not want to risk international conflagrations and the high human costs that result. Global organizations make many efforts to discourage countries from violating sovereign rights of other countries—all in hopes of keeping the peace and maintaining friendly relations across the international order.
Yet that long-held norm is breaking down. Western leaders were unprepared in 2014 when Russia invaded and annexed Crimea and then moved into the eastern part of Ukraine with the stated goal of protecting Russian interests. Crimea had been ceded to Ukraine in 1954 by the Soviet Union and had become a vital part of that country. The peninsula on the Black Sea used Ukrainian currency and had representation in the national parliament.
Despite international condemnation of the annexation, Russia refused to reverse course. Western leaders used impassioned rhetoric against the takeover, imposed trade and banking sanctions on the invader, and increased aid to Ukraine. Yet for more than two years the world has not figured out how to change the on-ground reality. Few leaders wanted to send troops to counter what they considered blatant Russian aggression.
Along with its rapidly increasing economic power, China has become much more active in regional and global affairs, and it has imposed limits on foreign organizations and multinational corporations that operate within its borders. It has challenged Japanese sovereignty over the Senkaku Islands in the East China Sea. Although these spots have been controlled by Japan for a long period of time, China asserted its territorial rights after oil reserves were discovered. It said that its geographical prerogatives pre-date those of Japan. The Chinese military sent boats and planes to the region in order to protect its own geographic claims and has installed surface-to-air missiles on one disputed island.14
In addition, China has built seven artificial islands on reefs in the South China Sea and declared Chinese sovereignty over the twelve miles surrounding each construction.15 This expansion in territorial claims has complicated U.S. military operations in the region and threatened the ability of some commercial ships to travel freely through those passages. These fears were heightened when China began installing long runways, military barracks, and missiles on the Paracel Islands. Neighboring countries—most of them U.S. allies and trading partners—worried that these moves were a sign of bald geopolitical ambitions on the part of China.16
In one encounter with an American military jet in the South China Sea, Chinese sailors sought to force the pilot away from the area. “Foreign military aircraft. This is Chinese navy. You are approaching our military alert zone. Leave immediately,” the unnamed person warned.17 Even though the plane was in international airspace, China claimed territorial rights in this encounter and sought to extend those rights to nearly 80 percent of the South China Sea. This put China in direct conflict with nations such as Vietnam, Malaysia, the Philippines, and Taiwan, all of which had sovereignty over parts of this waterway.
The Arab Spring uprisings caught nearly all governments and political commentators flat-footed. Most were surprised in 2010 when street protests erupted in Tunisia and sparked demonstrations in several Middle Eastern countries.18 Grievances against incompetence and corruption by authoritarian regimes throughout the Arab world resonated with ordinary people, thousands of whom surged into the region’s streets in an extraordinary series of protests. As they had done in other periods, governments moved to suppress the complaints and arrest protestors.
But the political movements toppled several authoritarian leaders who had seemed entrenched in power, notably President Hosni Mubarak in Egypt. Hardly any knowledgeable analyst anticipated the series of revolutions that quickly swept through North Africa and the Middle East. In short order, there were provisional governments in Tunisia, Libya, and Egypt. Syria and Yemen fell into devastating civil wars as rival factions jockeyed for political and economic power, and Libya has faced similar turmoil after the ouster and execution of Muammar Qaddafi.
Through these and other examples, I argue that many of the social, economic, and political forces that once constrained large-scale international change have grown weak. Old alignments have broken down and new ones are emerging—or in some cases new alignments are not even apparent as yet. Great power conflict, which seemed unimaginable in the nuclear era, has returned as a possible danger. The idea that nations would limit their territorial claims has given way to extensive jockeying among nations, testing geographic boundaries and violating traditional norms.