Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Wrecks the constitution

Lucas 16 – James W. Lucas is an attorney in New York City and member of the New York Bar., June 2nd 2016, "To Originate the Amendment of Errors: Reforming Article V to Facilitate State and Popular Engagement in Constitutional Amendment by James Lucas :: SSRN," No Publication

Madison was right – a convention is procedurally unworkable. In its time the Philadelphia convention of 1787 was not unusual. Many states had then recently held conventions and other assemblies to write state constitutions and address other matters, and the convention at Philadelphia had seemed to come off well.109 Of the framers, only Madison sensed that another national convention would be a far more difficult matter when left as procedurally vague as in Article V. Scholars and advocates have spilt much ink confidently announcing their numerous and contradictory solutions to these multitudinous issues. However, state legislators who are charged with the constitutional duty to actually decide whether to summon a second convention have time and time again emerged from the jungle of unresolved procedural questions to find themselves, not in the promised land of constitutional reform, but rather at the edge of a dangerous precipice whose base is shrouded in clouds of uncertainty. These legislators have repeatedly shied away from taking the leap into the unknown. No one can really assure these state legislators what constitutes a proper application for a convention, whether, how or to what extent Congress would count their applications, whether the convention could be limited as to subject matter, or who would go to the convention, how they would be selected and, most critically, how their votes would be counted. There can be no assurance that the federal Congress and/or courts will not control how these issues are decided or, conversely, if there is any predictable mechanism with certain authority to sort out all of these fundamental issues. Instead, there is a real possibility of the kind of constitutional confrontations predicted by Professor Tribe in testimony before the California state legislature. (Here “constitutional” does not mean technically legal under the Constitution, but rather fundamental political conflicts which could tear the very fabric of the governmental system created in 1787.) These are confrontations between Congress and the Supreme Court, the Supreme Court and the states, and the Congress and the convention itself if it ever came into being.110 After surveying these issues during the first great convention drive of recent years in the 1960s, Professor Robert Dixon concluded that even “without exhausting here all of the possible complexities, the state petition and federal convention route to constitutional amendment emerges as a veritable can of worms, and seems unlikely to be used successfully.”111 Experience since then has proven him right, as well as Madison. There has been no Article V convention, nor is there any realistic prospect of one. However, Professor Dixon went on to observe that “situations can be imagined even in this age where the disposition of congressional forces, including a Senate filibuster, could block the initiation of an amendment which, if submitted, would receive adequate popular support for ratification.”112 This brings us to our next question.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.