Fourth branch fails
Dyck & Lascher 19 [Joshua J. Dyck, Associate Professor of Political Science; Director of the Center for Public Opinion, University of Massachusetts Lowell, Edward L. Lascher, Jr, Professor and Chair, Department of Public Policy and Administration, California State University, Sacramento, “Expanding direct democracy won’t make Americans feel better about politics”, https://theconversation.com/expanding-direct-democracy-wont-make-americans-feel-better-about-politics-119799, 9/17/19, imp]
As Americans watch the Brexit-related , it is important to remember that the chaos there began in a form of direct democracy. When U.K. voters set in motion their exit from the European Union, .
Normally, such major policy would have been initiated, deliberated and voted on by their elected officials in Parliament.
The Brexit mess is an example of the disruptive potential of direct democracy, a practice that Americans leads to a healthier democratic society.
Recent polls show Americans are increasingly dissatisfied with their system of representative democracy. see sharp and unhealthy partisan divisions and lack confidence that the system will produce the results they desire.
Against this backdrop, some advocate for greater use of direct democracy. This includes , including California, Massachusetts and Michigan.
bypass the normal legislative process. They can be written by anyone and receive a public vote without input from lawmakers, provided enough petition signatures are obtained to get the initiative on the ballot.
Well-known initiatives have dealt with issues like , and . Advocates say could help address citizen disengagement from – and cynicism about – politics. Based on 15 years of , .
Progressives’ unfulfilled hope Claims promoting the positive benefits of direct democracy on voter turnout and engagement have appeared periodically since the wave of . Those reforms led to the establishment of the . Americans practice a form of by choosing among candidates for office. maintain that by voting directly on policy proposals, people become more knowledgeable about government, confident of their own abilities and positive about the capabilities of others. As political theorist , the “initiative and referendum can increase popular participation in and responsibility for government, provide a permanent instrument of civic education, and give popular talk the reality and discipline that it needs to be effective.” Beginning about two decades ago, some for the idea that greater use of direct democracy tools, especially the state ballot initiative, helps people get more interested in and engaged with politics and spurs more trust in government. Direct democracy has been popular with both political parties, and liberals as well as conservatives. Modern-day progressives often claim the ballot initiative can fix problems like gerrymandering, campaign finance abuses or growing income inequality. The Ballot Initiative Strategy Center “[W]e envision a future in which progressives have harnessed the power of ballot measures as proactive tools for success – to increase civic engagement, enact forward-looking policies, and strengthen progressive infrastructure in key states.” Yet not so long ago, that ballot initiatives and referendums were the , at least in the last 40 years. , sparking tax-cutting measures across the country. , states with ballot initiatives and voter-approved constitutional amendments passed laws defining marriage as between a man in a woman in more than 30 statewide votes between 1998 and 2011. Conflict and polarization
Drawing on a wide variety of data, we conclude in our book that the initiative process mainly encourages greater conflict rather than produces political and social benefits.
Ballot initiatives can increase voter turnout, which seems like positive news. But they do so through and encourage voting commonly based on fear .
Initiatives can also be a tool for ideological extremists and opportunists. They use the process to circumvent the American legislative process, long noted for its incrementalism and premium on compromise.
finds that the relationship between party identification and polarized issue attitudes – where Democrats increasingly take the more liberal position and Republicans take the more conservative position – is about 25%-45% bigger in states that frequently use the initiative than in noninitiative states.
Tyranny of the majority
Our research also confirms that initiatives often inflame occasional majority group voters. They do this with measures targeting the rights of minority group members.
This has been the case with attempts to and .
Examining all post-World War II ballot measures in California, we found numerous examples of votes that sought to curtail the rights of minority groups, including the LGBT community, racial/ethnic minorities and immigrants. Only .
The 1946 ballot initiative, Proposition 11, was called the “Fair Employment Practices Act” and on the basis of race, religion, color, national origin or ancestry. It received only 28% yes votes to 72% no.
This is exactly the “majority tyranny” that worried the American founders. that pure democracies were incompatible with “personal security” and “property rights.” Given the opportunity, he believed, the masses might vote away the rights and wealth of the elite. His ultimate point, that majorities can be myopic, has proven prescient.
Distrust in government
In the wake of all this conflict shows that frequent use of ballot initiatives makes citizens trust government less, not more. This is because initiative campaigns often stress that government is broken. Voters then conclude that we would have fewer direct democracy campaigns if government was more competent.