Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Courts backlash causes rollback and lack of enforcement

Strauss 1 — (David A. – Harry N. Wyatt Professor of Law at the University of Chicago, “The Irrelevance of Constitutional Amendments,” 114 Harv. L. Rev. 1457, http://chicagounbound.uchicago.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=2986&context=journal_articles)

In this respect, a mature society might be compared to a long-term contractual agreement. n10 The parties to such contracts often do not rely solely, or even substantially, on the text of the contract to govern their day-to-day relationship; they have developed extratextual understandings. Similarly, in a mature society, people accept the acts of legislatures, courts, and executive agencies - and the political and nonpolitical acts of their fellow citizens - even when those acts augment or arguably conflict with the foundational text. In a newly formed political society, any apparent deviation from the words of a constitution might be seen as revolutionary and might cause the society to break apart; in a mature society, relationships and patterns of trust are so well developed that that does not happen. As a result, by the time an Article V supermajority is galvanized into action, chances are good that much of society has already changed by one of these other means. And if a formal amendment process were unavailable, society would find another way to enforce the change it has determined to make - by legislation and judicial interpretation, or by alterations in social understandings and private sector behavior. The change might not be accomplished as neatly or as decisively; outliers might not be brought into line as quickly, for example. But relatively speaking, that is a detail. Those other institutions - not supermajoritarian constitutional amendments - will be the truly important means of constitutional change. This explains why, when [*1463] society has changed enough to produce a supermajority in favor of a formal amendment, the amendment is probably unnecessary. One cannot, however, just say simplistically that any set of political forces strong enough to bring about a constitutional amendment is strong enough to change society in some other way, because that is not always true. A supermajority might act, and adopt an amendment, even if society has not fundamentally changed. An amendment might represent a momentary high-water mark of popular sentiment on a question, or an effective effort by an interest group at the height of its power to secure its position. n11 At a later time, many people, even a majority, might decide that the amendment was a mistake - but there it is, entrenched in the Constitution. On these occasions the formal amendment will be relatively insignificant for a different reason. When there is no lasting social consensus behind a textual amendment, the change in the text of the Constitution is unlikely to make a lasting difference - at least if it seeks to affect society in an important way - unless society changes in the way that the amendment envisions. Until that happens, the amendment is likely to be evaded, or interpreted in a way that blunts its effectiveness. This is, in a sense, the other side of the fact that a mature society has a variety of institutions, in addition to the text of the Constitution, that can affect how the society operates. Those institutions can change society without changing the Constitution; but they can also keep society basically the same - perhaps with some struggle, but still basically the same - even if the text of the Constitution changes. This was, most notoriously, the story of the Fourteenth and, especially, the Fifteenth Amendment. The Fifteenth Amendment was somewhat effective in the short run, but within a generation it had been reduced to a nullity in the South. n12

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.