Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Congressional approval of logistics results in debate over the plan – ALSO ensures delay

Lawrence Schlam 94. Professor of Law, Northern Illinois University College of Law, State Constitutional Amending, Independent Interpretation, and Political Culture: A Case Study in Constitutional Stagnation, Winter 1994, 43 DePaul L. Rev. 269

Bills have been proposed in Congress setting out procedures that Congress must follow when calling and conducting a convention upon general application of the states. See, for example, S. 817, introduced by Senator Orrin Hatch, and S. 600, introduced by Senator Jesse Helms in 1981. A similar bill was proposed by Senator Sam Ervin in 1967. It passed the Senate in 1971, but died in the House Judiciary Committee. Most commentators believe such a law would be helpful in resolving conflicts in advance. See Article V and the Proposed Federal Constitutional Convention Procedures Bill, Report and Recommendation to the New York State Bar Association by the Committee on Federal Constitution, 3 CARDOZO L. REV. 529 (1982) [hereinafter N.Y. Bar Report]; Note, Proposed Legislation on the Convention Method of Amending the United States Constitution, 85 HARV. L. REV. 1612, 1615-29 (1972). Such "legislation would . . . help avoid the chaos and substantial delay which might result if Congress had to make, on an ad hoc basis following receipt of thirty-four applications, all decisions concerning the sufficiency of applications, the convening of the convention, and the procedures to be followed by it." Id. at 1617. As Senator Sam Ervin said in support of his bill: "The Constitution made the amendment process difficult, and properly so. It certainly was not the intention of the original Convention to make it impossible . . . . My bill seeks to preserve the symmetry of article V by implementing the convention alternative so as to make it a practicable but not easy method of constitutional amendment." Sam J. Ervin, Jr., Proposed Legislation to Implement the Convention Method of Amending the Constitution, 66 MICH. L. REV. 875, 895 (1968). But cf. Charles L. Black, Jr., Amending the Constitution: A Letter to a Congressman, 82 YALE L.J. 189, 193 (1972) (stating that the Ervin bill is unconstitutional, unwise, and could not bind Congress in the future). 

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.