The process of the counterplan alone links which makes link defense to ptx offense against the counterplan
Kay ’19 Richard S. Kay: Oliver Ellsworth Research Professor and Wallace Stevens Professor Emeritus, University of Connecticut School of Law “UPDATING THE CONSTITUTION: AMENDING, TINKERING, INTERPRETING” 67 Drake L. Rev. 887 (2019), HeinOnline
III. THE DANGERS OF "TINKERING" Even if the intrinsic difficulty of amendment were less challenging than it is usually agreed to be, it would still, in our current situation, face formidable obstacles. That is because any proposed constitutional change confronts a presumption that it poses serious legal and political risks.44 Studies of relative amendment flexibility have increasingly recognized the importance of these qualitative factors under the caption of "amendment culture. ' 45 The evaluation of such a culture presents obvious problems of measurement. Tom Ginsburg and James Melton have attempted to "operationalize amendment culture as the rate at which a country's previous constitution was amended" and concluded that, so measured, it was a better predictor of subsequent amendment rates than the formal attributes of the procedure.46 There is good reason to think that the current amendment culture in the United States exhibits a decided reluctance to change the Constitution. The clearest evidence of this attitude is the pronounced anxiety that appears whenever we get close to reaching the number of state legislatures necessary to approve a national constitutional convention 47 in light of worries about the extent of the changes such a convention might propose.48 The fear that any constitutional reform is likely to make things worse has a long history. The original ratification of the Constitution was closely contested and spawned "bitter disagreement of great ideological depth. 49 Despite this inauspicious beginning, the Constitution's authority was promptly accepted on all sides.50 Its former Anti-Federalist opponents, in fact, were soon citing "the strict words of this frail Constitution, insisting on a literal interpretation of a document that many of them had vilified on fundamental grounds. ' 51 The historian, Lance Banning, explained that the generation of the Constitution makers, steeped in classical republican thought, held a deep attachment to a mixed or balanced government. Maintaining such a government demanded an "unremitting attention to the stability of the state. ' 52 "According to their favorite histories of England and of Rome, constitutional change, like water, always flowed downhill."53 In light of these fears, the Constitution began to look better, even to those who had been its vigorous opponents. These beliefs set the stage for what Banning described as "constitutional apotheosis. '54 Even the disagreements that led to the great crisis of disunion in the mid-nineteenth century were not about the merits of the Constitution. Southern statespersons on the brink of secession continued to cite the Constitution in their defense.55 The prospects of amendment cannot be evaluated without taking into account the continued existence of U.S. "Constitution worship.”5 6 This attitude naturally discourages any attempts to improve or replace the original text.57 When the National Constitution Center's website posted the video of a debate on the propriety of a national amendment convention, it introduced the subject by noting, "[I]t is always tempting to invoke Article V to amend the Constitution-to 'fix' it, or 'restore' it, or 'improve' it. But, on the other hand, there is a substantial risk to tinkering with the Constitution: many amendments seem to have unintended consequences. '58 Worries about "tinkering with the Constitution" come up whenever constitutional revision is suggested. 59 That description connotes something trivial, something to be contrasted with the solemn majesty of the Constitution. In 1915, an article with that title, by Joseph R. Long, was published in the Yale Law Journal. 6° Long criticized a proposal to amend Article V to make the adoption of new amendments easier.61 The recent approval of the Sixteenth and Seventeenth Amendments, he argued, belied the claim that amendment was near impossible.62 But mainly, like Madison, he worried that too many revisions would "impair the dignity of a constitution. ' 63 The substantive reforms motivating many proposed amendments would be better accomplished by federal or state legislation. 64 The Constitution, he conceded, "is not perfect," but a careful and deliberate process was essential before altering a document that "is justly regarded as the greatest instrument of government ever ordained by man. 65 A more recent illustration of the same phenomenon is the response to efforts to procure a constitutional amendment giving Congress the power to punish desecration of the United States' flag. These proposals were seriously mooted in the wake of decisions by the Supreme Court, holding that prosecutions for flag defilement were prohibited by the First and Fourteenth Amendments. 66 Many people considered disrespect for the flag to be a grave offense, and opinion polls showed a fairly consistent majority favoring criminal prosecution. 67 Opponents of such a constitutional amendment, however, were able to mount effective arguments exactly along the lines discussed. 68 That is, they did not stress the rightness of constitutional protection for flag burners. Instead, they emphasized the dangers of toying with the Constitution and especially with the Bill of Rights.