Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

One amendment spurs others- history proves that it overcomes procedural barriers

Jackson 15 (Vicki, Thurgood Marshall Professor of Constitutional Law, Harvard Law School, The (myth of un)amendability of the US Constitution and the democratic component of constitutionalism, International Journal of Constitutional Law, Volume 13, Issue 3, July 2015, Pages 575–605, https://doi.org/10.1093/icon/mov050 )

Under existing procedures, it is not at all clear that the US amendment process should be regarded as “impossible” or even “close to impossible.” According to John R. Vile, a leading scholar of the US amendment process, of the thirty-three amendments that have been proposed by a two-thirds vote of both Houses of Congress, only six have failed to be enacted. 13 This record might be read to suggest that the major hurdle for amendments is the Congress, since the great majority of proposals that emerge are passed. How difficult is it to obtain agreement of two-thirds of both houses on proposals? It is not easy, to be sure. But if we consider the other situation in which the Constitution requires action by two-thirds of both Houses of Congress, the two-thirds of both houses requirement does not appear to be an “impermeable” barrier. To propose an amendment to the states requires two-thirds of both houses; to override a presidential veto also requires two-thirds of both houses. There have been approximately 110 congressional overrides of presidential vetoes since 1789 (including 15 during the highly confrontational presidency of Andrew Johnson). 14 Although this number is under 5 percent of the total number of presidential vetoes, even this data suggests that it is far from impossible to obtain agreement from the two houses by a two-thirds vote on substantive issues. Moreover, more meaningful figures focus on only those “regular” vetoes that were not “pocket vetoes” (which do not go back to Congress for possible override), 15 and on public (rather than private) bills. 16 Focusing on these categories of presidential vetoes of legislation likely to be of consequence and capable of being overridden by Congress, one finds that a significantly higher percentage have been overridden. For example, a 2013 study finds that looking only at “regular vetoes” since 1961, thirty-seven out of 233 vetoes were overridden—for a rate of 15.9 percent. 17 If two-thirds of both Houses of Congress can join together to override Presidential vetoes at these rates, then perhaps the requirement that two-thirds of each House join in proposing amendments may not, by itself, be quite so large an obstacle to proposing amendments as might be thought; and as noted, most amendments proposed by Congress have been ratified by the states. On the other hand, there are differences between veto overrides and proposals for amendment relating to ease of formulation, 18 and prior congressional investment, 19 that may make it more difficult for Congress to propose amendments than to override vetoes. The most recent proposal for an amendment from Congress—the Equal Rights Amendment proposed in 1972—failed to be ratified; although garnering ratifications in 35 states, it fell three states short of the 38 needed, illustrating that the requirement of ratification by three-fourths of the states poses an additional and real obstacle. Moreover, the first 12 amendments occurred very early in US history—by 1804. There may, then, be political phenomena that exist now, that did not exist before, that make amendment particularly difficult. 20 Indeed, to the extent that an amendment becomes a highly partisan issue, under conditions of relatively even partisan divide, the amending formula will pose a very substantial obstacle. 21 Whether in the long run that is a good or bad effect is debatable; slowing down amendment in times of intense partisan divides is not necessarily a bad thing. 22 Overriding presidential vetoes also appears to have varied in rate over time; the first override of a presidential veto was not until 1845 (Tyler’s administration), and the pace of overrides has varied with the political makeup of the Congress and the President (with thirty overrides, for example, from the beginning of President Nixon’s term until the end of President Reagan’s). 23 A different way of looking at things is to introduce the possibility of variation in amendment pace over different time periods. 24 The United States has had several long periods without amendments: from 1804 to 1865; from 1870 to 1913; and from 1971 to the present (with the bizarre exception of the 27th Amendment). 25 Between 1865 and 1870, there were three important amendments in the wake of the Civil War; and between 1913 and 1971 there were eleven amendments. We may not, then, know the extent to which the Article V process is “dead,” or simply quiescent, as it has been in the past. There is at least a possibility that enacting amendments makes enacting other amendments somewhat more likely—and conversely, that disuse of the amending procedures may increase the political or cultural resistance to their use. 26

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.