Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Kay ‘19

Richard S. Kay: Oliver Ellsworth Research Professor and Wallace Stevens Professor Emeritus, University of Connecticut School of Law “UPDATING THE CONSTITUTION: AMENDING, TINKERING, INTERPRETING, SYMPOSIUM DISCUSSION: KAY” APRIL 13, 2019, 67 Drake L. Rev. 909 (2019), HeinOnline

Audience Member: I think it's safe to say, or at least a consensus or a soft majority of the academic community would agree, that the Constitution should be amended in certain places. But the problem with that being that you need a pretty strong majority to accomplish that. I'm going to harken back to something Professor Levinson hit on. In this country where the Constitution is viewed as this absolute, almost biblical, document in its original sense, is there a way to repackage the republican view that it is important to amend the Constitution but alternatively that maybe the Constitution has served as sort of a baseline?

Kay: I can't say that it's impossible. Nothing lasts forever. This Constitution has lasted a long time and things in this country are really different now. Different in a way that I've never experienced in my unfortunately very long life. So, yes, it's possible. I think what you need is a crisis though that's kind of a tough thing to wish for. But, we may not see it. I won't see it.

Lisa Miller: Thank you very much, Richard. That was really interesting. I was intrigued by your comment about the amendments that were passed in the 19-teens at a moment you know when it looked like they weren't going to happen again. And it put me in mind me of a quote that I think is attributed to Winston Churchill, "That the Americans always do the right thing, but only after they've tried everything else first." And I think it's true that there have been moments where just enough people have said we've had it. Right, we're just going to think about the Twenty-Fourth Amendment, the poll tax, let's just be done with this. That's somewhat encouraging to me. I'm wondering if you have any thoughts on what issue or, issues or features of the Constitution might be, you know, close to in the next decade or so bubbling up.

Kay: There have been these periods; the progressive era in the 19-teens is not the only time it's happened. My colleagues will know better than I do. In the '60s, there were a whole bunch of amendments too, mainly about representation and voting. So, once you get one amendment through, and the world doesn't fall apart, then maybe there's room for another one if they are modest.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.