Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The counterplan’s incentive gives allies the political will cooperate

Morcos 21 – Pierre Morcos, visiting fellow at the Europe, Russia, and Eurasia program at the Center for Strategic and International Studies, career diplomat with the French Foreign Service and Deputy Head of the Strategic Affairs and Cybersecurity Division focusing on NATO and European Defense Issues, B.A. and M.P.A. from the Paris Institute of Political Studies (“’Lifting Up Our Values at Home’: How to Revitalize NATO’s Political Cohesion”, CSIS, 3/12/2021, https://www.csis.org/analysis/lifting-our-values-home-how-revitalize-natos-political-cohesion) FGY

First, allies should recommit to abide by the principles of the North Atlantic Treaty. These principles are often mentioned in NATO’s official communiqués in a cursory way, reflecting the limited attention given to them within the alliance. Allies should, as a first step, adopt at the highest level a declaration reaffirming the spirit and letter of the Washington Treaty. This could happen in conjunction with or, ideally, be imbedded in the new Strategic Concept that NATO is likely to launch later this year. While this declaration is not an end in itself, it is a first step to focus member countries and remind them what they will be held accountable for. Regarding the substance of such a pledge, the recent Reflection Group provides a good template with its proposed . This includes the North Atlantic Treaty articles and two new tenets focused on good behavior.

Second, NATO should monitor individual Allies’ compliance with these principles. To have a meaningful effect, such declaration needs to be complemented by an evaluation of its actual implementation, on the basis of an annual report prepared by the International Secretariat under the authority of the assistant secretary general for political affairs or the deputy secretary general. Building on existing metrics and findings (from  or other international organizations such as the  or ), this report would provide a basis for a periodic discussion on the political health of the alliance. Ideally, the assessment would be linked to NATO’s resilience metrics, in effect underscoring their link with external security threats. In addition to this cyclical process, an “emergency brake” mechanism, similar to what the European Union has established under its rule of law mechanism, could be put in place to allow an ally, or group of allies, to request a discussion at the North Atlantic Council or ministerial level when a serious violation of the declaration by an individual ally occurs. Such discussion would shed light on the problematic behavior of the ally in question and create political pressure in itself.

Third, NATO should raise the political cost for allies who break the rules. This is admittedly the most challenging course of action to implement given NATO’s consensus rule and the lack of legal mechanisms to sanction or expel members who violate NATO values and principles. As such, the alliance will need to be creative and use a mixture of incentives and disincentives, proceeding to this stage only when the above-mentioned monitoring and naming of violations of the code of conduct (behind closed doors) fail to achieve results. In terms of incentives, allies should make clear that decisions on NATO leadership positions, facility placement, or ministerial locations (once again planned to rotate among capitals) will consider respect for the code of good conduct. If this fails to induce better behavior, allies should move to publicize the infringement. If this further step also fails, allies would need to consider restrictions on the problem member, which could be decided by “” and encompass the following measures: suspension from participation in a specific committee, military planning, or exercises; suspension of intelligence sharing; or cancellation of exercises, ministerial meetings, or visits of NATO officials. Additionally, pressure can be brought to bear through bilateral or , in effect harnessing these instruments of power in support of NATO objectives.

Conclusion

Political will is vital to prevent such a framework from turning into a hollow shell. As the European Union has shown, actual implementation of the rules is not a given even when they are in place. NATO’s approach will also need to be proportional and graduated in order to give dialogue a chance to change behavior. If NATO moves too quickly or aggressively, it risks widening divisions in the alliance. Alternatively, if it moves too slowly or is overly technical in its approach, it will fail to achieve its broader political objective of repairing the values gap and restoring political cohesion. All in all, a careful balance between restraint and ambition will be paramount in this endeavor to renew NATO’s cohesion.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.