Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Current safeguards are insufficient – ensuring flexibility for potential curtailment is key

Lewis 19 – Dr. Larry Lewis, head of the CNA’s Center for Autonomy and AI, previous Senior Advisor to the Assistant Secretary of State responsible for human rights, lead analyst and co-author for the Joint Civilian Casualty Study in support of GEN Patraeus, subject matter expert on the subjects of joint and coalition interoperability, combat identification, and fratricide, Ph.D. in physical chemistry from Rice University (“Promoting Civilian Protection during Security Assistance: Learning from Yemen”, May 2019, https://www.cna.org/reports/2019/05/IRM-2019-U-019749-Final.pdf) FGY

Filling the policy gap: civilian protection and security assistance

The absence of a comprehensive US strategy in Yemen between 2015–2018 is a symptom of a larger problem: Although the US is the world’s largest dealer of military arms, it does not have a policy addressing civilian protection challenges that come when the recipient of military assistance uses force in armed conflict. The only safeguards are the Leahy law and a basic requirement that partner military forces comply with IHL.41 For example, DOD provides basic training regarding IHL through institutions such as Defense Institute of International Legal Studies (DIILS). Previous analysis shows that these safeguards are necessary but not sufficient for avoiding significant harm to civilians in armed conflict: many civilians can be harmed, and medical facilities and critical infrastructure can be damaged, even when military forces do not violate international law.42 Given this policy gap, how can the US manage differing interests and risks with respect to civilian protection? The overall construct in the Leahy law is instructive here; it includes two types of activities: 1. Improving operational effectiveness: general security assistance that can include military equipment and weapons, tactical training, and operational support 2. Promoting responsible behavior: training and education on IHL and human rights law to avoid gross violations of human rights, and working with the partner military and their justice system to promote accountability. When specific concerns arise with a partner, the first (improving operational effectiveness) can be curtailed or paused while the second is continued, or even intensified, with the intent of remediation and restoring the security assistance relationship. This overall approach can also be taken with civilian protection. The specific tools for promoting responsible behavior will differ, but the overall approach helps promote the interest of both the US and the partner force, and the security of civilians. This approach to managing risk in security assistance is shown in Figure 2.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.