Ensuring that alliances on emerging tech forefront democratic norms is vital for global democracy
Rasser 21, Senior Fellow and Director of the Technology and National Security Program at the Center for a New American Security (CNAS). Prior to joining CNAS, Mr. Rasser served as a senior intelligence officer and analyst at the Central Intelligence Agency (Martijin, “The case for an alliance of Techno-Democracies,” https://www.orfonline.org/expert-speak/the-case-for-an-alliance-of-techno-democracies/)
An effective tech alliance will need to balance the national interests and shared interests of its members, a difficult but feasible proposition when one considers common values and goals for economic competitiveness. A change in mindset in what ‘sovereignty’ in this context means is also necessary. Ultimately, interdependencies with allies and like-minded countries should be viewed foremost as a shared techno-democratic sovereignty, while those with autocratic countries such as China are fraught with economic and national security vulnerabilities that pose a direct challenge to liberal-democratic norms and values.
The other critique would be that a tech alliance would exacerbate a ‘Tech Cold War’, referring primarily to the strained US–China relationship. In less dramatic terms, this concerns a bifurcation of the tech ecosystem of China and that of the United States, as well as other tech-leading democracies. A partial divergence has already happened because leaders in both countries want it that way. American leaders are rightfully concerned about the risks associated with products from Chinese tech companies, and the Chinese Communist Party has been clear in word and deed that it seeks to be self-sufficient in a range of technology disciplines. China, like the US and its allies, also seeks greater resiliency and security in its supply chains.
American leaders are rightfully concerned about the risks associated with products from Chinese tech companies, and the Chinese Communist Party has been clear in word and deed that it seeks to be self-sufficient in a range of technology disciplines.
A tech alliance is unlikely to worsen these dynamics, nor is it destined to result in fully decoupled ecosystems. By cooperating and harmonising their efforts, the tech-leading democracies have considerable leverage and influence, making a more favourable dynamic plausible. The incentives and opportunity for China to establish an independent tech sphere of different standards, norms, and rules that other countries can join dwindle quickly if the countries accounting for most of the world’s GDP, science and tech infrastructure, and R&D spending offer a robust alternative. Should Beijing persist, it would isolate itself and any country that chose to follow from the bulk of the global economy.
A tech alliance is the best way to ensure technological leadership by the world’s techno-democracies. This leadership will be essential to safeguarding democratic institutions, norms, and values, and be a driver for sustainable and equitable economic growth around the world. Anything short of this goal carries major risk of a world marred by ascendant techno-authoritarianism, a direct challenge to the economic vitality, national security, and values of democratic nations across the globe. Ensuring that future never happens should be the clarion call to the leaders of the techno-democracies.